Man who lost eye after contracting flesh-eating infection is suing hospital that treated him | 7.30

Key Concepts

• Necrotising Fasciitis (NF): A rare, aggressive bacterial infection that rapidly spreads and destroys skin, fat, and the tissue covering muscles (fascia). It has a high mortality rate, estimated at approximately 30%.
• Sepsis: A life-threatening condition that arises when the body's response to an infection damages its own tissues and organs.
• Medical Misdiagnosis: The failure of a healthcare professional to correctly identify a patient's medical condition, leading to inappropriate or delayed treatment.
• Delayed Treatment: The failure to provide necessary medical intervention within an appropriate timeframe, which can worsen a patient's condition or lead to severe outcomes.
• Medical Negligence: A breach of the duty of care by a healthcare professional that results in harm to a patient.
• Induced Coma: A temporary coma caused by a drug, often used to protect the brain or allow the body to heal from severe injury or illness.
• Ophthalmology: The branch of medicine concerned with the study and treatment of disorders and diseases of the eye.
• Barwon Health: The public health service that operates University Hospital Geelong.

---

Ian Phillips's Ordeal: From Minor Injury to Life-Threatening Infection

The summary details the harrowing experience of Ian Phillips, who suffered a life-altering infection due to alleged medical negligence and misdiagnosis at University Hospital Geelong.

Initial Injury and Deterioration In April 2021, Ian Phillips, while celebrating Easter at home in Victoria's Southwest, was accidentally struck in the eyebrow by his three-year-old son with a wooden toy. The impact caused an instant, deep cut and significant bleeding. Ian initially visited his local GP, who glued the wound. However, his condition rapidly worsened, with severe swelling that completely closed his eye. Ian described his state, saying, "I feel like I'm dying... my head's going to blow up. It's just swelling so much." Recognizing the seriousness, he sought further medical attention.

Admission and Misdiagnosis at University Hospital Geelong Ian was admitted to University Hospital Geelong on April 6, 2021. Despite his wife Jade's concerns that his eye was infected, an ED intern, an ED consultant, and an ophthalmology registrar repeatedly dismissed the possibility of infection, diagnosing it as a "traumatic eye injury." They stated, "They just keep telling us it's not infected. It's not infection. It doesn't present as an infection." Ian's condition continued to deteriorate, as evidenced by his text messages to Jade: "Not good," "Still the same or worse," "Yep," "They don't listen," and "Swelling won't stop." A doctor even attempted to "pry open" his swollen eye with an icy pole stick, highlighting the extreme pressure and swelling.

Delayed Diagnosis of Necrotising Fasciitis It was not until 29 hours after Ian's initial arrival at University Hospital Geelong that a consultant ophthalmologist finally raised the possibility of necrotising fasciitis (NF). Dr. Rahul Shakrabati, an ophthalmologist not involved in Ian's case but experienced with NF, explained that it is "one of the worst, most aggressive infections that affects skin and deeper tissues," with a mortality rate of approximately 30%. He emphasized its catastrophic potential, particularly "around the face and head and neck" due to the proximity to the brain.

Emergency Treatment and Recovery Following the correct diagnosis, Ian was immediately rushed to the Royal Melbourne Hospital for emergency surgery to treat both necrotising fasciitis and sepsis. After the surgery, he was placed in an induced coma for two weeks. His wife, Jade, was prepared for the worst, stating, "I didn't think it was going to make it. That's what they kept preparing me for." Upon waking, Ian confirmed his suspicion, "I'm pretty sure my eye is gone," which was confirmed by medical staff. He immediately felt that "something had gone wrong in Jalong Hospital that they did not act quick enough."

Internal Review Findings and Legal Action Barwon Health, which runs University Hospital Geelong, conducted an internal review into Ian's care. This review, seen by 7:30, revealed critical failures:

• Delayed Antibiotics: Ian was given a range of painkillers (Endone, Morphine, Tramadol, Fentanyl) but no antibiotics until 24 hours after his emergency presentation.
• Inappropriate Antibiotics: Even when antibiotics were administered, they "weren't looking at the right kind of infection" and therefore "didn't use the right antibiotics."
• Missed Opportunities: The review identified three occasions within the first 17 hours of Ian's hospital stay where an infection diagnosis "could have been considered, but wasn't."
• Reasons for Low Suspicion: The review attributed the low suspicion for infection to the original injury not being contaminated and the rarity of necrotising fasciitis.

Lawyer Sher Liebey from Slater and Gordon is representing Ian and Jade in a lawsuit against Barwon Health for damages. Liebey asserts that "had even 24 hours after he presented at the hospital, they'd given him appropriate antibiotics that all of this this would never have happened." She described the outcome as "absolutely devastating," with Ian losing "about a quarter of his face, losing his eye, and being in a coma." Barwon Health declined to comment due to the ongoing legal proceedings.

Long-Term Impact and Loss of Trust Ian's life has been profoundly altered. As a mechanic who owns a workshop with his brother, his severely reduced peripheral vision makes his "fiddly work" challenging and frustrating. His favorite hobby, motocross, is now too unsafe to enjoy. He constantly experiences numbness in his face, serving as a "constant reminder," and the visible changes draw unwanted attention. For Jade, the experience has eroded her trust in the medical system, stating, "I don't trust any doctor anymore." She now second-guesses medical advice even for minor ailments in her children.

---

Synthesis and Conclusion

Ian Phillips's case serves as a stark illustration of the devastating consequences of medical misdiagnosis and delayed treatment, particularly when dealing with rare but aggressive conditions like necrotising fasciitis. The failure of University Hospital Geelong staff to promptly identify and treat the infection, despite clear signs and the wife's concerns, led to Ian losing an eye, a significant portion of his facial tissue, and enduring a life-threatening induced coma. The internal review highlighted critical lapses in care, including delayed and inappropriate antibiotic administration and missed opportunities for diagnosis. This ordeal has not only caused severe physical and psychological trauma to Ian but has also shattered his family's trust in the medical profession, underscoring the profound and lasting impact of medical negligence. The ongoing legal action seeks accountability for the catastrophic damages incurred.