Margaret Heffernan: Why it's time to forget the pecking order at work

The "Super Chicken" Model vs. Social Capital

1. The "Super Chicken" Experiment

Evolutionary biologist William Muir conducted a study on chickens to understand productivity. He divided chickens into two groups:

• Group 1 (Average): A standard flock left alone for six generations.
• Group 2 (Super Flock): A group composed of the most individually productive chickens, selected for breeding in each generation.

Findings: After six generations, the average group was healthy and highly productive. In the "Super Flock," all but three chickens were dead; the "super" individuals had achieved their success by aggressively suppressing the productivity of others. This serves as a metaphor for organizational cultures that prioritize individual "superstars" at the expense of team cohesion, leading to dysfunction, aggression, and waste.

2. Research on High-Performing Teams (MIT Study)

Researchers at MIT studied groups solving complex problems to identify what makes some teams more successful than others. They found that success was not driven by high individual IQ or the highest aggregate IQ, but by three specific characteristics:

• Social Sensitivity: High levels of empathy, measured by the "Reading the Mind in the Eyes" test.
• Equal Contribution: Members contributed roughly equal time to discussions; no single voice dominated, and there were no "passengers."
• Diversity: Successful groups often included more women, likely due to higher empathy scores or the introduction of diverse perspectives.

3. The Role of Helpfulness and Social Capital

The speaker argues that "helpfulness" is the core driver of successful teams, outperforming individual intelligence.

• Real-World Application (Arup): When faced with a complex engineering challenge for the Beijing Olympics, an engineer at Arup did not rely on individual research but sought help from a colleague who had designed a similar facility. The problem was solved in less than a day.
• Social Capital: Defined as the reliance and interdependency that builds trust. It is the "mortar" that holds the "bricks" (individuals) together.
• Practical Implementation: Companies like SAP and various tech firms emphasize that technology is not the solution to collaboration; rather, it is about people getting to know each other. Strategies include:
  • Fika: A Swedish term for collective restoration through coffee breaks.
  • Physical Environment: Banning desk coffee cups to encourage interaction or creating shared spaces like vegetable gardens.
  • Synchronization: Alex Pentland’s research showed that synchronizing coffee breaks increased profits by $15 million and employee satisfaction by 10%.

4. Redefining Leadership and Success

The speaker challenges the traditional "heroic soloist" model of leadership and the "talent contest" approach to management.

• The Montreal Protocol Case Study: When tasked with phasing out CFCs, Frank Maslin’s team succeeded by adhering to three principles:
  1. No Stars: Every team member’s perspective is valid.
  2. High Standards: Aiming for the "best imaginable."
  3. Leadership Support: The leader provided "air cover" and removed themselves from the day-to-day to prevent power imbalances from disrupting the team.
• Key Argument: Money often erodes social connectedness. Instead, leaders should create conditions where everyone can do their most courageous thinking together.

5. Notable Quotes

• "If the only way the most productive can be successful is by suppressing the productivity of the rest, then we badly need to find a better way to work and a richer way to live."
• "Companies don't have ideas; only people do."
• "What matters is the mortar, not just the bricks."
• "Bringing out the best in others is how they found the best in themselves."

---

Key Concepts

• Super Chicken Model: A management style that rewards individual superstars, leading to internal competition and organizational decay.
• Social Capital: The network of relationships, trust, and interdependency among people that enables a society or organization to function effectively.
• Social Sensitivity: The ability to perceive and respond to the emotions and needs of others (empathy).
• Candor: Open, honest, and direct communication, which is essential for turning messy, early-stage ideas into great ones.
• Fika: A Swedish cultural practice of taking a break to socialize, fostering collective restoration and social bonding.
• Air Cover: A leadership role where the manager protects the team from external interference and political pressure, allowing them to focus on the task.