You can’t fire a bot: The blunt truth about AI slop and your job
By The New Stack
Key Concepts
- Writer’s Strategic AI Approach: Building and integrating AI, prioritizing enterprise needs (security, data governance), and evolving towards smaller, specialized, self-evolving models.
- The Rise of AI Agents: Transition from LLMs to agentic systems capable of autonomous decision-making and tool invocation.
- Human-AI Collaboration: AI augmenting human capabilities, shifting roles towards management and oversight of AI agents.
- Societal Impact of AI: Potential for positive change (reducing fatalities) alongside significant workforce disruption requiring proactive policy and retraining.
- The Importance of Critical Thinking: AI necessitates enhanced critical thinking skills to evaluate and validate AI-generated content.
Writer’s Evolution & AI Strategy
Writer began alongside the early development of LLMs (circa 5-6 years ago) with a unique focus on enterprise applications. Unlike research-driven AI companies, Writer prioritized data retention, deployment models (single vs. multi-tenant), security, and data governance from the outset. Initially focused on marketing content, Writer now addresses “the written word” across all departments, primarily for internal use cases, aiming to solve complex operational problems. The company has invested heavily in building its own LLMs (the Palmyra series) to ensure data privacy and model stability, initially viewing reliance on external models as risky – “like swapping a Porsche for a Kia.” However, Writer is now adopting a pragmatic approach, supporting models on Amazon Bedrock and exploring open-weight/open-source models for specific tasks like knowledge graph extraction.
The Shift to Agentic Systems & Model Architecture
The evolution of AI has progressed from basic LLMs to “custom apps” (prompt chaining, model selection) and now to “agentic systems” – autonomous, skill-based systems capable of making decisions and invoking tools. Writer’s “Writer Agent” embodies this agentic approach. The company is shifting towards a new model architecture based on smaller, specialized models that learn from usage and evolve continuously, driven by cost reduction, accuracy, and speed. This contrasts with the unsustainable trend of building ever-larger models. These “self-evolving models” operate in the background, adapting without constant retraining, and belong to the user, with Writer providing the infrastructure and tools for secure deployment. A crucial component of this architecture is a robust “context graph” – a model-agnostic representation of an organization’s data, workflows, and decision-making processes – and a “judgment graph” to capture implicit decision-making and ensure accountability.
The Future of Work & Human Oversight
AI is not expected to replace humans but to augment their capabilities, leading to a workforce where everyone becomes a “manager” – managing agents, hybrid teams, and making critical judgment calls. The limiting factor in AI adoption will be “supervision” rather than execution. This parallels the impact of technologies like spreadsheets, where new skills and roles emerged. Accountability remains with humans, even when using AI tools.
Societal Implications & Workforce Adaptation
The potential of AI, particularly self-driving technology, is significant, with the possibility of drastically reducing global traffic fatalities (currently numbering in the “hundreds of thousands if not millions”). However, this progress will disrupt the labor market, notably the trucking industry, which employs “hundreds of thousands if not more” people represented by the Teamsters union. The initial rollout of self-driving technology is envisioned to begin with long-haul trucking, potentially with a human driver and a “navigator” for urban environments.
The most pressing policy gap isn’t in short-lived skills like “prompt engineering” (dismissed as a “hoax”), but in equipping the workforce with skills to interact with AI – “learning how to interact with it, learning how to manage agents, learning how to build evals for your domain.” This requires initiatives from companies and, crucially, government at all levels through retraining and job training programs. The speaker emphasized the urgency, noting the retiring “boomer generation” and the emergence of “AI native” younger generations.
The Need for Critical Thinking & Policy Response
AI’s proliferation of generated content elevates the importance of skills like editing and fact-checking, acting as a “forcing function” for critical thinking to combat “fake news [and] false information.” AI necessitates ensuring that machine outputs are not “nonsense.” The speaker acknowledged the slow response of politicians to these challenges and highlighted the general population’s lack of preparedness for the changes AI will bring: “people are not prepared for what’s coming at them and people don’t know what’s coming at them.”
Conclusion
Writer’s approach to AI emphasizes enterprise-grade security, data governance, and a shift towards smaller, self-evolving models. Beyond the technical advancements, the discussion underscores the profound societal implications of AI, demanding proactive policy adjustments, workforce retraining, and a renewed focus on critical thinking skills to navigate a future increasingly shaped by intelligent agents. The core takeaway is that successful AI integration requires not just technological innovation, but also a thoughtful and strategic approach to human-AI collaboration and societal adaptation.
Chat with this Video
AI-PoweredHi! I can answer questions about this video "You can’t fire a bot: The blunt truth about AI slop and your job". What would you like to know?