Why is the UK so bad at getting stuff done?

Digital ID Scheme U-Turn & Northern Rail Plans – January 14th Analysis

Key Concepts:

• Digital ID Scheme: A government initiative aiming to provide a digital means of verifying identity, initially intended for employment checks.
• HS2 (High Speed 2): A previously planned high-speed railway project in the UK, partially cancelled by the current government.
• Northern Powerhouse Rail: A proposed rail upgrade project for the North of England, aiming to improve connectivity.
• U-Turn: A reversal of policy or decision by the government.
• Non-Doms: Individuals who are not domiciled in the UK for tax purposes, a topic of recent financial policy changes.
• Net Migration: The difference between the number of immigrants entering and emigrants leaving a country.

1. Digital ID Scheme Reversal

The government has significantly rolled back its digital ID scheme, removing the mandatory requirement for working-age individuals to use it to prove their right to work in the UK. This represents a major U-turn, as the initial justification for the scheme, announced in September, centered around combating illegal working.

• Initial Justification & Opposition: Karma (likely referring to Home Secretary James Cleverly) initially framed the scheme as a tool to reduce illegal employment, but employers already had existing obligations to conduct checks, including digital ones using passports. Nearly 3 million people signed petitions opposing the scheme.
• Funding Concerns: The scheme is facing funding difficulties, with the Chief Secretary to the Prime Minister reportedly sending a “begging letter” to Whitehall departments seeking financial support.
• Ministerial Pushback: Josh Simons, the recently appointed minister responsible for digital ID, reportedly advocated for the removal of the compulsory element.
• Shift in Rationale: The government is now attempting to reposition the scheme as a convenience for citizens, though its viability remains uncertain. A government source, quoted in Playbook, stated the mandatory aspect was “stopping conversation about what digital IDs could be used for generally,” fearing unintended consequences like barring a 65-year-old in a rural area without access.
• Technical Challenges: Implementing a digital ID scheme requires building or integrating multiple databases, a historically complex and costly undertaking in Whitehall, as evidenced by the Universal Credit rollout.

2. HS2 Land & Northern Powerhouse Rail Announcement

The government announced it will retain land previously earmarked for sale following the cancellation of the northern leg of the HS2 high-speed rail project. Instead, it will pursue a new rail scheme along the Birmingham-Manchester corridor.

• Historical Context: Rishi Sunak cancelled the northern leg of HS2, a decision opposed by former Prime Ministers David Cameron and George Osborne.
• Strategic U-Turn: Officials reportedly anticipated this reversal from the outset, suggesting the land sale was a temporary measure.
• Differentiation from HS2: The government is emphasizing that the new rail route will not be high-speed, with trains running at slower speeds to avoid replicating HS2.
• Investment & Timeline: The government is initially investing £1.1 billion towards the estimated £45 billion needed for the Northern Powerhouse Rail upgrades, with no firm completion date announced.
• Skepticism & Regional Concerns: There is skepticism about the project's long-term viability, with concerns that it may be subject to future cuts. The focus on the Birmingham-Manchester corridor has also raised concerns in the North East, which feels overlooked.

3. Broader Political & Strategic Implications

The discussion highlighted broader themes of government policy-making, public perception, and the challenges of implementing large-scale projects.

• Starmer’s Association & Public Backlash: Kier Starmer’s personal association with the compulsory digital ID element proved to be a significant vulnerability, as public opposition was stronger than anticipated.
• Importance of Cross-Party Consensus: The speakers emphasized the need for cross-party consensus to ensure the longevity of major projects, citing the failures of ID cards and HS2 as examples of projects that lacked broad support. Successful projects like the Bank of England, Devolution, and Universal Credit benefited from early buy-in.
• Impact of Social Media: The ability to rapidly mobilize public opposition through social media (“flash mob mentality”) presents a challenge for governments.
• Shifting Priorities & Immigration: The U-turn on digital ID may reflect a shift in government priorities, with immigration becoming less of a dominant issue.
• Openness to High-Net-Worth Individuals: Rachel Reeves, the Shadow Chancellor, signaled a more welcoming approach to attracting high-net-worth individuals and skilled workers to the UK, potentially reversing recent policies regarding “non-doms.”
• Davos & International Engagement: The government is actively promoting the UK as an attractive investment destination at the World Economic Forum in Davos, with Reeves meeting with key figures like Jamie Dimon.

4. Notable Quotes

• “It feels like sort of Starmerism live in action.” – Commenting on the rapid changes and reversals surrounding the digital ID scheme.
• “Unless you announce a scheme and immediately get buy in from the public… there is never a second chance with these projects.” – Highlighting the importance of public support for long-term initiatives.
• “The north of England is an untapped gold reserve that we haven't yet used.” – A quote from a government official regarding the Northern Powerhouse Rail project, which was met with skepticism.
• “If you make something less flashy and easier to cancel that it's less likely to happen.” – Reflecting on the potential for future reversals of the Northern Powerhouse Rail plan.

5. Technical Terms & Concepts

• Whitehall: The center of the UK government administration.
• Domicile: The country a person considers their permanent home, relevant for tax purposes.
• Net Migration: The difference between immigration and emigration.
• Universal Credit: A consolidated welfare benefit in the UK.
• Playbook: A political newsletter providing insider information on Westminster.

Conclusion:

The day’s events demonstrate a pattern of significant U-turns by the government, particularly regarding the digital ID scheme and HS2. These reversals highlight the challenges of implementing large-scale projects, the importance of public and cross-party support, and the impact of shifting political priorities. The government is attempting to reposition itself as pro-business and open to investment, but faces skepticism regarding its long-term commitment to infrastructure projects in the North of England. The rapid pace of change and the influence of external events (like the situation in Iran) add further complexity to the political landscape.