Who will be California’s next governor? | The Economist

Key Concepts

• Californable: A term used to describe the state of California as dysfunctional, burdened by bureaucracy, and suffering from poor governance.
• Structural Deficits: A fiscal condition where a government's expenditures consistently exceed its revenues, requiring ongoing adjustments to plug budget holes.
• Ballot Initiatives: Direct democracy measures that have historically tied California’s budget and housing policies in knots, often leading to unintended regulatory consequences.
• Populist Movement: A political approach emphasizing the concerns of "the people" against an established elite, central to the campaign strategy of candidates like Steve Hilton.
• Single-payer Healthcare: A system where the state provides healthcare coverage for all residents, a key progressive policy position discussed in the race.
• Flat Tax: A tax system where everyone pays the same percentage of income, proposed by Steve Hilton to replace California’s progressive income tax structure.

---

1. The State of California: Dysfunction vs. Economic Powerhouse

The discussion centers on whether the "caricature" of California as a dystopian, dysfunctional state is accurate.

• Criticisms: The state faces significant challenges, including high housing costs, slow infrastructure development, and a bloated bureaucracy. These issues are often attributed to decades-old ballot measures and environmental/labor regulations that have been co-opted to block development.
• Economic Reality: Despite these issues, California remains an economic powerhouse, home to Silicon Valley, Hollywood, and massive manufacturing and agricultural sectors.
• Fiscal Standing: The state budget has expanded significantly under Governor Gavin Newsom. A report from the Legislative Analyst’s Office indicates that rising costs are driven by inflated existing programs and increased state employee compensation rather than new initiatives, leading to persistent structural deficits.

2. The Democratic Field and Campaign Dynamics

The Democratic candidates are described as lacking the "star power" of previous governors like Arnold Schwarzenegger or Jerry Brown.

• Tom Steyer: A billionaire candidate utilizing a self-financed campaign. He is noted for spending 20 times more on advertising than his closest competitor and leveraging social media influencers. While he takes progressive stances (e.g., single-payer healthcare, antagonizing big oil), he has also proposed "wonky" and pragmatic reforms to housing ballot measures.
• Xavier Becerra: Despite a high-profile resume (Congressman, Attorney General, HHS Secretary), he faces criticism for being a "lightweight" and failing to provide specific policy plans for affordability and housing, leading to voter uncertainty.
• Tactical Voting: There is a concern that media-driven panic regarding the possibility of two Republicans making the runoff has forced Democrats into "safe" but uninspiring choices rather than voting for the most effective candidate.

3. The Republican Strategy: Steve Hilton

Steve Hilton, a former advisor to David Cameron and a Fox News host, is running with Donald Trump’s endorsement.

• The Populist Pitch: Hilton argues that California has "gone off the rails" after 16 years of one-party Democratic rule. He points to high poverty rates and the high cost of living as evidence of failure.
• Tax Reform Proposal: Hilton proposes eliminating state income tax for those earning under $100,000 and implementing a flat tax for those above that threshold. He argues this is "pro-worker" and "pro-growth," intended to stop the exodus of wealth creators and entrepreneurs.
• The Trump Burden: Hilton’s reliance on Donald Trump’s endorsement is a double-edged sword. While it appeals to a specific base, Trump’s historical unpopularity in California makes it difficult for Hilton to position himself as an independent-minded, centrist Republican—a strategy that has historically been the only path to victory for Republicans in the state.

4. Synthesis and Conclusion

The California gubernatorial race highlights a fundamental tension in American politics: the struggle between the "Republican caricature" of a failing, over-regulated state and the reality of a complex, high-performing economy. The Democratic field is struggling to find a successor to the "superstar" era of governors, while the Republican candidate is attempting to navigate the difficult path of running as a Trump-endorsed populist in a state where the former president is deeply unpopular. The ultimate outcome will likely hinge on whether voters prioritize the "affordability crisis" and a desire for change, or whether they remain wary of the specific brand of populism offered by the Republican opposition.