What if It's Still Early? | TCAF 244

Key Concepts

• Capex Recovery: A cycle where corporations increase capital expenditure (spending on infrastructure, technology, and equipment) to drive future growth.
• Multiple Compression: A scenario where earnings grow, but the stock price does not rise at the same rate, leading to a lower Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio.
• S&P 493: The S&P 500 index excluding the "Magnificent Seven" (the largest tech-heavy stocks), used to measure the breadth of market performance.
• Unit Labor Costs: A key metric for corporate profit margins; lower unit labor costs relative to productivity typically correlate with higher profit margins.
• Idiosyncratic vs. Systemic: Distinguishing between risks or behaviors specific to a few companies (idiosyncratic) versus those affecting the entire market (systemic).
• Availability Bias: The tendency to overvalue recent, memorable events (like the 2000 dot-com bubble) when assessing current market conditions.

---

1. Market Outlook and Earnings Growth

The discussion highlights that the S&P 500 is experiencing a robust earnings growth cycle, with Goldman Sachs raising its year-end target to 8,000. A critical point is that this growth is becoming "diffuse"—spreading beyond the "Magnificent Seven" to the broader S&P 493.

• Earnings Recovery: The market is in the early stages (approximately four months in) of an earnings recovery for the S&P 493, following a three-year period of contraction.
• Valuation: Despite all-time highs, the market is not in a bubble. The recent multiple compression—where earnings grew while prices remained relatively flat—suggests investors are skeptical of the sustainability of this growth, which paradoxically provides a "wall of worry" for the market to climb.

2. The Capex Cycle and AI

Denise Chisum argues that the current wave of capital expenditure is fundamentally different from the 2000 bubble.

• Cash Flow vs. Equity Funding: The 2000 bubble was fueled by equity issuance (speculative capital). Today’s capex is largely funded by the free cash flow of highly profitable, established companies.
• Industrial Transformation: Tech companies are evolving into "modern industrials." While they are spending heavily on infrastructure (AI compute), they are maintaining high margins.
• Semiconductors: While the sector has seen massive gains (up 100% over the last year), this is supported by an anomaly in earnings growth. Historically, when industries see such growth, they have a 65% probability of outperforming again in the following year.

3. Macroeconomic Factors: Inflation and the Fed

The conversation challenges the binary "hike vs. cut" narrative often seen in media.

• Oil and the Fed: Contrary to popular belief, oil price spikes function more like a tax on the consumer than a catalyst for broad-based inflation. Historically, the Federal Reserve is less likely to hike rates following an oil shock because it acts as a drag on growth.
• Shelter Component: Core CPI is currently distorted by the shelter component. Excluding shelter, core CPI is at 2.3%, suggesting inflation is less severe than the headline numbers imply.
• Fed Policy: The market is currently in a "sweet spot" where inflation is between 3% and 4%. If the Fed hikes rates due to growth (as indicated by strong durable goods orders), it is a reflection of a healthy cycle rather than a deterrent to it.

4. IPOs and Market Liquidity

The potential IPOs of major private companies like SpaceX, OpenAI, and Anthropic (estimated to raise ~$170 billion) have caused concern regarding liquidity.

• Absorption: While there may be short-term idiosyncratic volatility as portfolio managers rebalance to accommodate these new listings, the long-term driver of the market remains earnings. The market has historically proven capable of absorbing large equity issuances when the underlying earnings growth is strong.

5. Notable Quotes

• "The equity market doesn't always reflect good times. In fact... it's more often the hedge against bad times." — Denise Chisum
• "The more uncertain the environment, the higher the odds of the stock market advancing." — Denise Chisum
• "In today's modern digital markets, in a bull market, there will always be maniacal behavior... but in the aggregate, the fact that we are not outpacing earnings growth, I think the market is being pretty sober." — Michael

Synthesis/Conclusion

The main takeaway is that the current bull market is supported by a durable, broad-based earnings recovery rather than speculative mania. Investors are cautioned against "availability bias"—the tendency to fear a repeat of the 2000 bubble—and are encouraged to look at the data, which shows that profit margins are expanding due to restrained wage growth and productivity gains. The market's skepticism, evidenced by multiple compression, is viewed as a healthy sign that the rally has room to continue.