What does Germany's Friedrich Merz want from China during his trip? | DW News

Germany-China Relations: Chancellor Scholz's Visit - A Detailed Analysis

Key Concepts:

• Trade Deficit: The imbalance in trade between Germany and China, with German exports to China decreasing and Chinese brands becoming more competitive.
• Dual-Use Technology: Materials and technology that can be used for both civilian and military purposes, raising concerns about their potential contribution to Russia’s war effort.
• Systemic Rival: The European perspective of China as a competitor challenging the existing international order.
• No-Limits Partnership: The strategic alliance between China and Russia, characterized by increasing cooperation and mutual support.
• EV Overcapacity: The excess production capacity of electric vehicles in China, leading to a push for export markets.
• Reminbi (RMB): The official currency of China.

I. Initial Diplomatic Exchange & Economic Significance

German Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s visit to China marks a significant attempt to “reset ties” with Beijing, particularly in the context of heightened global volatility following the return of Donald Trump to the US presidency. President Xi Jinping expressed a desire to elevate Sino-German relations to a “new level,” emphasizing the need for strengthened strategic communication and mutual trust, especially given the increasingly “turbulent and complex” world. Both leaders acknowledged the importance of a stable relationship for broader China-Europe relations and global stability. Chancellor Scholz highlighted the decades of successful economic cooperation between the two nations, stating, “We have worked very well together over the past few decades. Germany has enjoyed great economic success in China for decades.” A key outcome of the initial meetings was China’s agreement to purchase up to 120 aircraft from European manufacturer Airbus. China is currently Germany’s largest trading partner, becoming increasingly vital for German exporters due to the unpredictability of the US market and fluctuating tariff rates.

II. Thorny Trade Issues & Chinese Counterarguments

Despite the positive rhetoric, significant trade issues were brought to the table by Chancellor Scholz. A major concern is the substantial trade deficit between Germany and China, coupled with declining German exports and market share within China. German companies are facing increasing competition from Chinese brands globally. Scholz presented three specific requests to the Chinese leadership: a reduction in Chinese subsidies for domestic manufacturers (arguing they create an unfair competitive advantage), an appreciation of the Reminbi (RMB), and continued access to critical raw materials from China for German industries.

President Xi Jinping countered by urging Germany and Europe to view China “with objective and rational eyes,” rejecting the framing of China as a “systemic rival.” He emphasized China’s role as a responsible and dependable global power, contrasting it with the perceived instability under the Trump administration.

III. Geopolitical Concerns: Ukraine & Taiwan

The visit also addressed sensitive geopolitical issues, namely the war in Ukraine and the status of Taiwan. Chancellor Scholz criticized China’s support for Russia, specifically citing the purchase of Russian oil and gas and the export of “dual-use” materials and technology that could be utilized in the war effort. He urged China to curb these exports, stating that China’s actions and words are closely monitored in Moscow.

However, there was little indication of a breakthrough on these issues. President Xi reiterated the importance of diplomacy in resolving the Ukraine conflict and called for equal participation in talks, a position unlikely to significantly alter China’s current stance given its strengthening “no-limits partnership” with Russia.

IV. China’s Framing of the Visit & Strategic Objectives

China is strategically framing Scholz’s visit as a reaffirmation of its partnership with Germany and a demonstration of its role as a responsible actor on the world stage. This aligns with China’s broader effort to present itself as a stable and dependable power, particularly in contrast to the US under Donald Trump. The influx of Western leaders – including Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and UK Labour Leader Keir Starmer – in recent weeks serves to bolster President Xi’s image as a strong leader in a changing global order. According to Claus Sun, an analyst at the MA Institute for China Studies, “what counts for a win for China is that it becomes an alternative option, especially under the turbulent Trump era, for Western leaders.”

V. Specifics of EV Technology & Potential Concessions

The discussion extended to the electric vehicle (EV) sector, where China has surpassed European automakers. The analyst, Claus Sun, highlighted China’s desire for access to the European market, particularly given the overcapacity of its EV industry and economic pressures within China. Germany, however, is seeking concessions in return.

Potential concessions from China include price controls on EV exports to Europe, addressing the overcapacity issue domestically. However, the extent to which China will concede remains uncertain, particularly regarding its strategic partnership with Russia and concerns about human rights in Xinjiang.

VI. Addressing Human Rights & Russia’s War: Public vs. Real Business

The analyst suggests that issues like human rights (specifically regarding the Uyghur minority in Xinjiang) and China’s support for Russia are likely to be addressed as matters of public record, fulfilling a requirement for European audiences, while the “real business” of economic cooperation proceeds. China is unlikely to significantly alter its stance on Russia, given its perceived national interests. The leverage for Germany to compel change on these issues is limited, and China appears willing to discuss economic matters to deflect attention from these more sensitive political concerns. As stated by Claus Sun, “China’s happy to talk about economy and these to kind of get these more hard politics issue…being put away.”

VII. Data & Statistics

• China is Germany’s largest trading partner.
• German exports to China are decreasing.
• China has agreed to purchase up to 120 Airbus aircraft.
• China and Russia share a “no-limits partnership.”

Conclusion:

Chancellor Scholz’s visit to China represents a complex interplay of economic necessity and geopolitical concerns. While both sides expressed a desire for strengthened relations, significant challenges remain, particularly regarding trade imbalances, China’s support for Russia, and human rights issues. China appears to be successfully positioning itself as a viable alternative partner to the US, leveraging the current global instability to its advantage. The success of the visit will ultimately be measured not by signed agreements, but by China’s actions and whether it demonstrates a willingness to address the concerns raised by Germany and the broader European community. The emphasis on maintaining stability in the economic relationship, even amidst disagreements, suggests a pragmatic approach from both sides.