‘We failed’: Minns vows ‘not to make the same mistake twice’ after Bondi attack

New South Wales Premier’s Response to Bondi Junction Attack & Security Measures

Key Concepts:

• Royal Commission: A formal public inquiry into a matter of public importance, with powers to compel evidence.
• Operation Shelter: The large-scale police operation launched in New South Wales following the Bondi Junction attack.
• CSG (Community Security Group): Private security personnel employed by Jewish community organizations.
• De-escalation Protocol: A process established with the Jewish Board of Deputies regarding the arming of CSG personnel.
• Hate Preachers: Individuals promoting hatred or vilification based on race or religion.
• Anti-Semitism: Hostility to or prejudice against Jews.
• AIO (Australian Intelligence Organisation): Responsible for assessing national security threat levels.

1. Calls for a Federal Royal Commission & NSW Response

The families of the Bondi Junction attack victims are calling for a federal royal commission. The NSW Premier acknowledges the importance of a royal commission within New South Wales, stating it’s crucial for providing up-to-date information to families and the community, and for learning from the event. However, the Premier deferred questions regarding a federal commission to the federal government, noting that state commissions may not have the same powers to compel evidence from federal intelligence agencies. The Premier emphasized the need for a comprehensive response, acknowledging this is the worst terrorism event to affect the state and country. He believes a discerning judge can manage a royal commission alongside ongoing criminal trials to expedite answers.

2. Security Enhancements & Arming of CSG

A significant focus of the response is bolstering security for the Jewish community. The Premier revealed discussions are underway regarding arming CSG personnel, particularly for events like Hanukkah by the Sea, after numerous members of the Jewish community expressed feeling unsafe. This decision is being made in consultation with the Jewish Board of Deputies through a “de-escalation protocol.” While CSG is already armed at static locations like synagogues and schools, extending this to events requires careful consideration. The Premier stated, “if in the end the safest way…is having armed guards then I think that’s a small price to pay.” He acknowledged opposition to this decision but firmly believes change is necessary.

3. Operation Shelter & Long-Term Security Commitment

Operation Shelter is currently one of the largest police operations in NSW history. The Premier stressed the importance of maintaining a high level of security beyond immediate media attention, stating, “The security for our community is the most important responsibility of any government.” He admitted a failure in security on December 14th and vowed not to repeat the mistake. The Premier also indicated consideration of requesting assistance from the Australian Army, particularly as Operation Shelter evolves, recognizing the need for sustained security measures. He referenced security changes in cities like Rome and Paris as precedents.

4. Addressing Hate Preaching & Legislative Action

The Premier announced plans for legislation to swiftly shut down prayer halls operating without consent, potentially by disconnecting utilities. He described the goal as making it “as easy as turning off a light.” This is aimed at combating “hate preachers” who spread hatred, particularly targeting those already identified as racists by the courts. The legislation will focus on individuals breaching existing laws prohibiting hate speech and vilification based on race. The definition of “hate preachers” will encompass those violating the law, including those targeting LGBT issues.

5. Timeline for Royal Commission & Terms of Reference

The Premier stated a royal commission is being actively considered, with discussions underway regarding terms of reference and a suitable commissioner. He emphasized the need for thorough consultation with the affected community, particularly the Jewish community. A key element of the inquiry will be an examination of the escalation of anti-Semitism over the past two years, tracing the connection between comments at rallies and the violent attack in Bondi. While a specific date hasn’t been set, the Premier aims to establish the commission “as soon as possible.”

6. Emergency Response Review & Lessons Learned

The Premier addressed questions regarding the emergency response, specifically why firefighters weren’t requested at the scene despite possessing advanced trauma kits. He stated he doesn’t have a definitive answer, noting it was an operational decision. Initial briefings suggest lessons from a previous incident (Bondi Junction attack) were implemented, improving access for paramedics. He acknowledged the need to investigate if further improvements are necessary. He also noted the importance of having sufficient resources available for potential future incidents.

7. New Year’s Eve Security & Defiance of Terrorism

The Premier addressed concerns about New Year’s Eve security, stating he hopes celebrations will proceed despite the heightened threat level. He urged the community to demonstrate defiance against terrorism, refusing to be intimidated. He acknowledged a visible increase in police presence, including armed officers, may be confronting but emphasized it’s necessary to ensure public safety. He expressed a desire to build a stronger, more resilient community in the wake of the attack.

8. Federal Government Coordination & Powers

The Premier reiterated his inability to speak for the federal government regarding a federal royal commission. He expressed confidence that a NSW royal commission would have the necessary powers to access information from any agency or individual. He deferred questions about the national terrorism threat level to AIO, noting it has been increased.

Notable Quote:

“If in the end the safest way of…being an extreme deterrent to someone committing this offense again…is having armed guards then I think that’s a small price to pay.” – NSW Premier Chris Minns.

Synthesis/Conclusion:

The NSW Premier is responding to the Bondi Junction attack with a multi-faceted approach focused on bolstering security, particularly for the Jewish community, investigating the root causes of the attack, and ensuring long-term resilience. The proposed security enhancements, including arming CSG personnel and potentially deploying the army, represent a significant shift in security protocols. The commitment to a royal commission, coupled with legislative action against hate preaching, demonstrates a determination to address both the immediate and underlying factors contributing to the attack. The Premier’s emphasis on sustained security and community resilience underscores the gravity of the situation and the long-term commitment required to address the threat of terrorism.