US, Turkey, Qatar envoys arrive for Gaza talks in Egypt | DW News

Key Concepts Gaza War (Israel-Hamas conflict), Indirect Negotiations (Egypt), Trump's 20-point proposal, Ceasefire, Hostage Release, Israeli Military Withdrawal, Hamas Disarmament, Humanitarian Crisis (Gaza), Famine, Accusations of Genocide, US Leverage, Netanyahu's Political Pressure, Palestinian Statehood.

---

Ongoing Peace Negotiations and the Devastation in Gaza

Indirect negotiations to end the war in Gaza are gaining momentum in Egypt, coinciding with the two-year anniversary of the conflict. US President Donald Trump expressed optimism, stating he saw "a real chance of a breakthrough" and that America would ensure adherence to any agreed deal. His special envoy, Steve Witkoff, and son-in-law, Jared Kushner, are expected to attend the meetings, alongside the Qatari prime minister and Turkey's intelligence chief. These talks are based on Trump's 20-point proposal.

Despite the peace efforts, Israel's bombing campaign in the Gaza Strip continues. The Israeli offensive has caused immense destruction, damaging nearly 80% of buildings since its inception two years ago. Analysis by the UN indicates the rapid pace of destruction, with over 100,000 buildings damaged by January 2024, primarily in the northern region around Gaza City. The destruction intensified as Israel escalated its offensive in central and southern Gaza, leading to entire neighborhoods in the southern city of Khan Younis being "nearly razed to the ground." Additionally, nearly 80% of Gaza's roads are also damaged.

The Catastrophic Humanitarian Situation in Gaza

DW correspondent Emily Gordine reported from Jerusalem on the dire conditions in Gaza, stating that Gazans are "barely coping" as life has been "upended and devastated" by the war, now entering its third year.

Specific Details on Humanitarian Impact:

• Casualties: The majority of those killed in Israeli airstrikes have been civilians, many of them children. The total death toll in Gaza stands at approximately 67,000 people. Entire families have been "wiped out in a single strike."
• Displacement and Housing: 92% of all homes have been destroyed, forcing many people to live in tents. 95% of the population is displaced, often far from their original homes, which are now difficult to locate due to the extensive damage.
• Infrastructure: Barely any schools, universities, or hospitals remain intact.
• Food Security: New UN figures from August indicate that only about 1.5% of cropland in Gaza can still be farmed, suggesting a heavy future dependence on aid. Israel's restriction of aid throughout the war has led to famine setting in the territory, according to the UN.
• Accusations of Genocide: These conditions have led to accusations of genocide in Gaza by various human rights organizations, including Israeli ones, and an independent UN commission. Israel has strongly rejected these accusations.
• Journalist Access: The Israeli government has refused to allow international journalists into Gaza. The only glimpses international journalists have captured, often through air drops, confirm that Gaza has been "essentially been raised to the ground."

Status and Sticking Points of the Negotiations

The indirect talks between Israel and Hamas began on Monday in Egypt, with a second day held at the Egyptian Red Sea resort of Sharm al-Sheikh. The arrival of President Trump's special envoy Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner signals "crunch time" for these negotiations, with Trump's team reportedly "pushing both sides quite hard" to reach an agreement.

Crucial Sticking Points:

• Israeli Military Withdrawal: The scope of Israel's military withdrawal from Gaza remains a significant point of contention.
• American Guarantees: Hamas seeks American guarantees that Israel will not resume the war once Israeli hostages are released, a concern that arose in March.
• Hamas Disarmament: Hamas's disarmament is a major obstacle, as the group has so far refused to comply. A Hamas spokesman reiterated the group's insistence on Israel's full withdrawal from the territory as a condition for a ceasefire deal based on Trump's plan.

Analysis of Negotiating Dynamics and Political Pressures

Giorgio Cafiero, CEO and founder of Gulf State Analytics, provided insights into the negotiating strategies and political pressures.

Hamas's Negotiating Strategy:

• Hamas is "in principle willing to disarm," a long-standing stance.
• However, Hamas demands guarantees: that Israel will not restart the war and that Israeli forces will fully withdraw from Gaza.
• Without these guarantees, Hamas leadership and many Palestinians in Gaza view disarmament as a "suicidal move."
• Cafiero identifies Hamas disarmament as "one of the main sticking points, perhaps the main sticking point," posing a challenge for mediators like Witkoff, the Qataris, Turks, and Egyptians.

The US Role and Leverage:

• The plan is "Trump's plan" and "US-backed," highlighting the significant American involvement.
• The US is considered the "one power in the world that really has a leverage over Israel" necessary to pressure Prime Minister Netanyahu's government into an agreement.
• The presence of high-ranking US officials is crucial and puts pressure on both sides to "accelerate the process."

Political Pressure on Netanyahu:

• Domestic Pressure: There have been numerous protests in Israel by citizens demanding an end to the war for the return of Israeli captives. However, Cafiero argues these protestors are "not Netanyahu's constituents" and have not exerted "significant pressure" to alter his calculations.
• External Pressure (More Significant):
  • From Trump/US: This is the "real pressure that matters," as Netanyahu needs the support of the United States.
  • From Europe: Changing public attitudes in many European countries and gestures toward Palestinian statehood by EU members and the UK also constitute a form of pressure that Netanyahu "can't ignore."
• Internal Counter-Pressure: Netanyahu also faces pressure from right-wing extremists in his cabinet who oppose negotiations with Hamas and do not want the conflict to end.
• Netanyahu's Understanding: Ultimately, Netanyahu understands that Israel requires the support of the United States and, to a lesser extent, Europe.

Optimism and Limitations of the Peace Plan

Cafiero offered a realistic assessment of the potential outcomes of Trump's 20-point peace plan.

Potential Realistic Outcomes:

• The return of Israeli captives held in Gaza.
• The freeing of many Palestinians held in Israeli prisons (both before and after October 7, 2023).
• A significant influx of desperately needed humanitarian assistance into Gaza.
• An end, or at least a pause, to the war.

Limitations of the Plan:

• Cafiero believes the plan will not address the "underlying issues of this conflict."
• Fundamental questions such as "post-governance in Gaza" and "Palestinian statehood" are "not being addressed right now."

Conclusion

The ongoing indirect peace talks, spearheaded by the US and based on Trump's 20-point proposal, represent a critical effort to de-escalate the two-year-long conflict in Gaza. While there's a perceived "real chance of a breakthrough" for a ceasefire, hostage release, and increased humanitarian aid, significant obstacles remain, particularly concerning Israeli military withdrawal and Hamas disarmament. The humanitarian crisis in Gaza is catastrophic, marked by widespread destruction, displacement, famine, and accusations of genocide, underscoring the urgency of a resolution. While the US exerts considerable leverage, and European attitudes are shifting, the plan is primarily seen as a means to achieve immediate relief and prisoner exchanges rather than a comprehensive solution to the conflict's deep-rooted political issues like post-war governance or Palestinian statehood.