They're teenagers — and they chase ICE

Key Concepts

• ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement): A federal law enforcement agency under the U.S. Department of Homeland Security responsible for enforcing immigration laws.
• Citizen Journalism/Documentation: The act of recording public events, specifically law enforcement activities, to provide transparency and accountability.
• Body-Worn Cameras (BWC): Recording devices used by law enforcement; the lack of consistent usage by agents is a primary motivation for the subjects' activities.
• Homeschooling/Mobile Education: An educational framework that allows the subjects to integrate real-world field experience with academic study.

---

Overview of the Subjects and Mission

Ben and Sam Lumen, teenage brothers (ages 16 and 17) from Chicago, have dedicated themselves to documenting the activities of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents. Their mission is rooted in the belief that federal agents often operate without sufficient oversight, particularly regarding the use of body-worn cameras. By filming these interactions, they aim to provide the American public with an unfiltered view of how immigration enforcement is conducted on the ground.

Motivation and Methodology

The brothers’ involvement intensified following the shooting death of Renee Good in Minneapolis. Driven by a sense of urgency, they traveled six hours from Chicago to Minneapolis to monitor and record ICE operations.

• Documentation Strategy: The brothers act as independent observers, positioning themselves at the scene of arrests to capture footage. They view their presence as a form of "real-life" counter-action against what they perceive as the unchecked power of federal agents.
• Educational Integration: Because the brothers are homeschooled, they have adopted a mobile learning model. They carry their textbooks and laptops with them, allowing them to maintain their academic progress while traveling to different locations to conduct their documentation work.

Key Arguments and Perspectives

• Accountability through Transparency: The core argument presented by the brothers is that the lack of mandatory, consistent body-cam usage by ICE agents necessitates civilian oversight. They believe that by documenting these interactions, they can hold agents accountable for their conduct.
• Risk and Resilience: When questioned about their safety, the brothers express a stoic perspective. They acknowledge that "they [ICE agents] are going to do what they are going to do," suggesting that the potential for intimidation or danger does not outweigh the perceived moral necessity of their work. They characterize the opposition they face—often from bystanders or agents—as similar to "internet trolls in real life."

Notable Statements

• Ben and Sam Lumen: "Our goal here is just documenting everything. A lot of agents don't even wear body cams and also so the American people can see what's actually happening."
• On Fear: When asked if they are afraid, the brothers maintain that they cannot "just ignore it and let it [happen]," emphasizing that their commitment to the cause supersedes their personal fear.

Synthesis and Conclusion

The Lumen brothers represent a growing trend of youth-led activism that utilizes digital media to challenge institutional authority. By bridging the gap between traditional education and active civic engagement, they have created a framework where they can document sensitive law enforcement interactions in real-time. Their work highlights a significant tension in modern American society: the demand for transparency in federal immigration enforcement versus the operational autonomy of the agencies involved. Their efforts serve as a case study in how mobile technology and a commitment to documentation can be used to influence public discourse on civil rights and government accountability.