The German' government's plan to protect itself from hybrid threats | DW News

Key Concepts

• Civil Defense (Zivilschutz/Bevölkerungsschutz): Non-military measures to protect the civilian population during crises or war.
• Hybrid Threats: A combination of military and non-military tactics (e.g., cyberattacks, disinformation, infrastructure sabotage) used to destabilize a state.
• Pakt für den Bevölkerungsschutz: A strategic framework and investment program aimed at restructuring Germany’s civil defense architecture.
• Security Architecture: The integrated system of military and civil measures designed to ensure national stability.

---

1. The Strategic Shift in German Security Policy

The German government is undergoing a fundamental shift in its security policy, moving away from the assumption that military defense is sufficient on its own. Officials emphasize that while Germany is not currently at war, the global geopolitical climate is increasingly volatile. The core argument presented is that "there is no military security against external threats without a functioning civil defense." This represents a move toward a holistic security architecture where the protection of the civilian population is a primary pillar.

2. The "Pakt für den Bevölkerungsschutz" (Pact for Civil Protection)

The government has introduced the Pakt für den Bevölkerungsschutz, which is described as more than just an investment program; it is a structural overhaul of how Germany prepares for disasters and attacks.

• Addressing Under-investment: The plan serves as a corrective measure for decades of insufficient funding and neglect in civil defense infrastructure.
• Hybrid Threat Mitigation: The pact is specifically designed to build resilience against modern "hybrid threats," which blur the lines between peace and war.

3. Implementation and Methodology

The government’s approach involves both technological upgrades and educational initiatives:

• Technological Integration: Development and improvement of warning applications for smartphones to ensure real-time communication with the public during emergencies.
• Educational Outreach: Integrating civil defense training directly into school curricula to foster a culture of preparedness among the younger generation.
• International Benchmarking: Germany is looking to Scandinavia as a model, noting that these nations are several years ahead in their civil defense preparedness. Furthermore, the ongoing conflict in Ukraine serves as a real-world case study, demonstrating the necessity of being able to defend against an aggressor and maintain societal functionality under duress.

4. Key Perspectives and Statements

The urgency of this shift is underscored by high-level government officials:

• The "Nothing" Principle: The transcript highlights the sentiment: "Ohne Sicherheit ist alles andere nichts" (Without security, everything else is nothing), emphasizing that security is the foundational requirement for all other societal functions.
• The Ukrainian Example: The defense minister’s recent visit to Ukraine is cited as a sobering reminder of the reality of modern defense, where the ability to protect the population is inextricably linked to the ability to repel an attacker.

5. Synthesis and Conclusion

The German government is transitioning from a reactive to a proactive stance regarding national security. By acknowledging that military strength is insufficient without a robust civil defense, the state is prioritizing the Pakt für den Bevölkerungsschutz. The strategy relies on three main pillars: correcting historical under-investment, adopting best practices from Scandinavian models, and preparing the public through education and improved digital warning systems. The ultimate goal is to create a resilient society capable of withstanding the complexities of modern hybrid warfare and large-scale crises.