Taking Stock: Will tax incentives boost home building in Canada?

Key Concepts

• Housing Market Index (HMI): A metric used by the Canadian Homebuilders Association to measure builder sentiment.
• Purpose-Built Rental (PBR): Residential buildings constructed specifically for the rental market rather than for individual ownership.
• Red Seal Program: A standard for trades training in Canada; however, the construction industry notes that less than 25% of residential workers fall under this formal apprenticeship framework.
• Development Charges: Fees levied by municipalities on developers, which have been rising and impacting project affordability.
• Stress Test: Regulatory requirements for mortgage qualification that builders argue need to be more dynamic to improve market access.

---

1. Economic Briefs and Market Indicators

• Inflation: Canada’s inflation rate reached 2.8% in April, driven primarily by energy costs linked to geopolitical tensions in Iran and the expiration of carbon tax relief measures. Food inflation moderated to 3.5% (down from 4% in March), while core inflation remained stable at 2.1%.
• Energy Sector: The International Energy Agency (IEA) predicts a decline in global oil demand by 420,000 barrels per day, citing collapsing inventories and reduced consumption in the petrochemical and aviation sectors.
• Corporate Activity:
  • Cohere: The Canadian AI firm is acquiring Reliant AI (specializing in drug discovery) following its planned merger with Germany’s Aleph Alpha.
  • Agnico Eagle Mines: Committed to a $2.4 billion redevelopment of the Hope Bay gold mine in Nunavut, targeting an annual output of 435,000 ounces for at least 11 years.
• Infrastructure: A report has questioned the validity of the Churchill Falls power contract replacement deal between Newfoundland and Labrador and Quebec, prompting calls for an independent review.

---

2. The State of the Canadian Housing Market

Kevin Lee, CEO of the Canadian Homebuilders Association, provided an assessment of the current housing crisis:

• Builder Sentiment: The Housing Market Index is at all-time lows, signaling a continued decline in housing starts, particularly for ownership-based units.
• The Shift to Rentals: There has been a significant structural shift in the market. In 2021, 69% of housing starts were for ownership; by the first quarter of this year, that figure dropped below 50%, with purpose-built rentals "masking" the decline in ownership-based construction.
• Financial Barriers:
  • Financing Requirements: Developers typically require 70–80% of units to be pre-sold before securing construction financing, which is currently difficult in a slow market.
  • Taxation and Fees: High municipal development charges and sales taxes (GST/HST) are major hurdles. While tax incentives in Ontario are a positive step, the lack of similar agreements in other provinces, such as British Columbia, remains a concern.

---

3. Labor and Policy Frameworks

• Skilled Worker Shortage: Lee emphasized that the industry faces a chronic shortage of skilled labor.
• Apprenticeship Limitations: While the government’s investment in the Red Seal apprenticeship program is welcomed, Lee noted that it only covers a fraction of the workforce. Outside of Quebec, only about 10% of residential construction workers are unionized, meaning federal funding flowing through unions does not reach the vast majority of the industry.
• Policy Recommendations: To improve market conditions, the industry is calling for:
  • More dynamic mortgage stress tests.
  • Standardization of federal-provincial housing deals across all provinces.
  • A reduction in the frequency and complexity of building code changes, which contribute to rising costs.

---

4. Synthesis and Conclusion

The Canadian housing sector is currently in a state of stagnation, characterized by record-low builder confidence and a pivot toward rental construction to compensate for the collapse of the ownership market. While government interventions—such as tax offsets and infrastructure support—are viewed as necessary, they are currently insufficient due to limited geographic implementation and a mismatch between funding models (like the Red Seal program) and the actual composition of the residential construction workforce. The path to recovery requires a multi-pronged approach involving regulatory reform, municipal fee stabilization, and broader access to financing for developers.