Stock Markets Rose on US-Iran Deal Hopes. Ilya Spivak Warns This Will Not Save Them From Inflation

Key Concepts

• Macroeconomic Divergence: The disconnect between optimistic stock market sentiment and the underlying reality of sticky inflation and geopolitical instability.
• Energy Shock: The ongoing impact of the Strait of Hormuz closure on global oil and natural gas prices.
• Sticky Inflation: Inflation that persists despite central bank efforts, driven by core services and energy-related knock-on effects.
• Inventory Depletion: The use of global strategic petroleum reserves (SPR) to mask the severity of the current oil supply shock.
• Cognitive Dissonance: The market’s tendency to ignore negative macroeconomic data in favor of short-term, optimistic news cycles (e.g., Axios headlines).

---

1. Market Analysis and Price Action

The speaker, Ilya Spivak (Head of Global Macro at Tasty Live), highlights a significant divergence in market behavior. While the S&P 500 reached new highs based on optimistic headlines regarding a potential Iran-US peace deal, other asset classes remain skeptical:

• S&P 500 vs. NASDAQ: The S&P 500 broke through swing highs, but the NASDAQ failed to follow suit. Momentum indicators, specifically the Relative Strength Index (RSI) and declining volumes, suggest the rally lacks underlying strength.
• Bonds and Gold: Both continue to show a series of lower highs and lower lows, indicating that the "war trade" (risk aversion and higher interest rate expectations) remains intact.
• Crude Oil and Natural Gas: Despite news of a potential ceasefire, energy prices remain elevated. The speaker notes that even if the Strait of Hormuz were reopened immediately, it would take months to normalize supply chains.

2. The "Strait of Hormuz" Geopolitical Framework

The speaker argues that the market is misinterpreting the Iran situation.

• Negotiating Leverage: Iran has an incentive to maintain the blockade to gain leverage for a more favorable final deal, including demands for joint control of the strait.
• The "Six-Month" Reality: Even under a best-case scenario, the logistical damage and disruption to shipping flows would take at least six months to resolve.
• US Stance: The US government maintains that the strait must remain open to all, creating a high-stakes standoff that is far from a "solved" problem.

3. Economic Data and Inflationary Pressures

The latest PCE (Personal Consumption Expenditures) data confirms that inflation is accelerating:

• Core Inflation: Core services (excluding housing) and core goods are both accelerating, driven by the "knock-on effects" of the energy shock (e.g., increased costs in warehousing and truck freight).
• GDP Revision: First-quarter GDP was revised downward from 2% to 1.6%, indicating a less vigorous economic rebound than previously reported.
• AI Buildout: While residential investment (AI data centers) has been a primary driver of growth, these projects are not immune to the rising costs of capital and energy.

4. Inventory Depletion and Future Risks

A critical point made is that the global economy is currently "digesting" the oil shock by burning through strategic reserves.

• Strategic Reserves: Global inventories (including the US SPR) are at their lowest levels since mid-2023.
• The "Timer": The speaker suggests there is an inherent expiration date on this insulation strategy. Once inventories are depleted, the full force of the energy shock will likely hit the economy, especially as Europe begins to stockpile for winter.

5. Strategic Positioning and Outlook

The speaker maintains a bearish stance on risk assets, anticipating that the market will eventually be forced to reconcile with the macro reality:

• Methodology: The speaker is positioned for higher rates by being short gold, long the US dollar, and short bonds (using put verticals and outright puts).
• Stock Market Strategy: Rather than fighting the S&P 500 rally directly, the speaker is selling calls to offset losses from previous bearish positions and to capitalize on the lack of momentum.
• Time Horizon: Positions are pushed out 50+ days to allow time for the market to "catch up" with the macro reality of sticky inflation and energy constraints.

6. Notable Quotes

• "The market is choosing to believe that things are good again at least for today."
• "Data centers don't magically sprout out of the ground when you sprinkle AI fairy dust on them."
• "This is the kind of news flow that's disappointed before... the market finally gets into buy the rumor, sell the news mode."

Synthesis

The core takeaway is that the current stock market rally is built on fragile sentiment rather than economic fundamentals. While the market is currently ignoring the "sticky" nature of inflation and the long-term geopolitical risks in the Middle East, the underlying data—specifically the depletion of global oil inventories and the acceleration of core services inflation—suggests that a correction is likely. The speaker advises caution, noting that the market's current "cognitive dissonance" will eventually be corrected by the reality of higher interest rates and persistent energy costs.