Silver Breaks $50 Again - What's Next? | Andy Schectman

Key Concepts

• Silver Price Surge: Silver has surpassed $50 per ounce, a significant increase of 65-70% year-to-date.
• Correction and Overbought Conditions: The recent sharp correction in silver prices was an inevitable consequence of parabolic appreciation (40% in two months), indicating overbought conditions.
• Institutional Positioning: Large institutions were caught "offside" by silver's rapid rise, potentially facing existential threats, leading to efforts to slow its ascent.
• Critical Mineral Status: Silver is now officially recognized as a critical mineral by the US government, implying a price floor and potential government purchases.
• China's Export Restrictions: China, the largest silver refiner, is implementing new rules for state-traded exports, requiring individual government licenses for all silver exports starting in 2026, signaling a strategic shift towards state-managed supply.
• Geopolitical Resource Redefinition: Silver is transitioning from an industrial metal to a geopolitical resource or strategic element.
• Triple-Digit Silver Predictions: Analysts like Keith Neumeyer and Michael Oliver predict triple-digit silver prices within the next few quarters.
• Consolidation in Retail: The rising cost of inventory, insurance, and shipping will likely lead to consolidation among local coin shops and smaller dealers.
• Logistical Challenges: Increased silver prices exacerbate logistical challenges for shipping, with valuation limits on registered mail and rising costs for carriers like FedEx.
• "Junk Silver" Value: Dimes, quarters, and half dollars minted before 1965 (junk silver) are considered a good value, especially when purchased at or near spot price, due to their divisibility and utility.
• US Mint Inefficiency: The US Mint has historically demonstrated inefficiency in production, with demand often exceeding supply, particularly for American Eagles.
• Silver Bar Premiums: Premiums on silver bars, often imported from Switzerland, are higher due to supply chain disruptions and tariffs.
• Domestic Refiners and Alternative Coins: 1-ounce rounds from domestic refiners and coins from other major mints (Krugerands, Brittanias, Philharmonics) are suggested as alternatives to bars.
• China's Impact on LBMA: China's export restrictions and the US critical mineral designation signal a strategic asset view of silver, potentially leading to supply crises and rising strategic value.
• Rehypothecation and Market Cap: Silver's market is heavily rehypothecated (the same contract sold multiple times), with a small market cap relative to trading volume, making it susceptible to explosive price movements.
• Government Involvement: Governments are increasingly viewing silver as a strategic asset, adding a new dynamic to the market alongside industrial demand and investor interest.
• Gold Revaluation (July 4, 2026): There is a strong indication that gold may be revalued on July 4, 2026, as mentioned in the "Genius Act" and by figures like Judy Shelton.
• Gold-Silver Ratio: The historical gold-silver ratio is around 42:1, with a geologic ratio of 7:1, suggesting significant upside potential for silver.
• Technical Analysis: Cup and handle formations in silver's price chart suggest a potential target of $96.
• BRICS+ Impact: The BRICS+ initiative and a potential pivot away from the US dollar and Treasuries towards physical assets are discussed.
• Government Aid in Mining: Governments are likely to aid in mining endeavors for critical minerals, including fast-tracking permits and investing in mining companies.
• Mining Stocks: First Majestic is highlighted as a pure silver mining play, with royalty companies like Franco Nevada, Royal Gold, and Silver Wheaton also recommended.
• Fiat Currency Inflation: The crushing weight of inflation in fiat currency is leading to a potential shift towards precious metals-based currency.
• Dollar Debasement: The rise in gold and silver is seen as a strategy to combat dollar debasement and reshore manufacturing.
• Weekly Specials: Discussion of specific coin specials, including Brilliant Uncirculated St. Gaudens $20 gold pieces, 2025 Silver Maple Leafs, and Palladium.

---

Silver's Price Surge and Market Dynamics

The discussion begins with the significant news that silver has surpassed $50 per ounce this morning, marking a 65-70% increase year-to-date. Host Donigan Kaiser notes the considerable "hand-wringing" over the past two weeks, despite analysts like Michael Oliver and Christopher Muan maintaining that fundamental drivers for a major bull market remain intact.

Andy Schechman, CEO of Miles Franklin Precious Metals, explains that the recent sharp correction was an inevitable consequence of parabolic appreciation, where silver appreciated 40% in two months. This indicates overbought conditions, which should not be surprising. He emphasizes that this is a "high stakes game" where major institutions were caught "offside" and faced "existential threats," leading them to actively try and slow down the rise.

Silver's Redefinition as a Strategic Resource

A key development highlighted is silver's official designation as a critical mineral by the US government. This move is seen as putting a floor under the price and potentially leading to government purchases.

Simultaneously, China's Ministry of Commerce (MFCOM) has issued new rules regarding state-traded exports, aiming to curtail exports starting in 2026. All silver exports from China will require individual government licenses from Beijing. Schechman interprets this as classifying silver as a resource of national interest, not just for the US but globally, signaling a strategic shift towards state-managed supply. He argues that silver is being redefined from an industrial metal into a geopolitical resource or strategic element.

Impact on Retail and Logistics

The conversation shifts to the implications of potentially reaching triple-digit silver, a prediction made by Keith Neumeyer and Michael Oliver. Schechman anticipates consolidation within the retail silver market, with smaller dealers struggling to maintain inventory due to exponentially increasing costs of inventory, insurance, and shipping.

He elaborates on the logistical challenges, stating that even with robust shipping arrangements like those with FedEx, they do not ship more than $150,000 of product per package. Registered mail has a limit of $50,000, which is insufficient for even a tube of gold eagles. The rising costs for carriers like FedEx mean that prices and insurance will inevitably increase, further pushing towards consolidation into larger companies.

Best Silver Buys and Considerations

When asked about the best silver buy outside of junk silver, Schechman first addresses junk silver (dimes, quarters, half dollars minted before 1965). He considers it the best value if purchased at or near spot price, as it carries no opportunity cost or added premium. He contrasts this with its behavior during the pandemic, where premiums were second only to American Eagles due to its utility and divisibility.

He notes the inefficiency of the US Mint, citing an anecdote from Jack Surman, who developed the Silver Eagle program, about being instructed by then-Secretary of the Treasury Janet Yellen to produce as few Silver Eagles as possible.

Regarding other options, Schechman advises against silver bars due to potential tariffs and higher premiums on imported products. He suggests 1-ounce rounds from domestic refiners as a good alternative. He also recommends coins from other major mints like South Africa (Krugerands), Australia (Kangaroos), and the UK (Brittanias), as their premiums are more reasonable compared to the inflated bar market. He specifically mentions the 2026 Silver Kangaroo as an example.

China's Export Restrictions and the LBMA

The impact of China restricting silver exports is discussed in relation to the LBMA (London Bullion Market Association). Schechman reiterates that both China and the US now view silver as a strategic asset, not just a commodity. This, coupled with silver's essential role in solar panels, electric vehicles, semiconductors, and defense, points to a potential supply crisis and rising strategic value.

He describes the silver market as "massively rehypothecated," meaning the same contract is sold repeatedly, creating a significant problem given its relatively small market cap. He believes major global players understand this and are engaged in a "quiet rush to accumulate resources." He emphasizes that silver is a necessary element for moving energy and civilizations, being the best conductor of heat and electricity known to science. He notes that obtaining silver is already difficult for many globally, and this could rapidly change if governments adopt protectionist policies.

Suppressing Spot Price and Future Battles

Schechman asserts that the spot price cannot be suppressed indefinitely over time, and the market's direction will ultimately prevail. He anticipates a future "battle" for silver involving industrials (e.g., Tesla, Sony, Samsung), hedge funds, investors, and now governments. He highlights a statement from "Bald Guy Money" (Roger) about the US military alone needing 50-100 million ounces of silver, suggesting this is a low estimate. The combination of government support, demand, and restricted supply makes it nearly impossible to hold the price down long-term.

Gold Revaluation and Silver's Correlation

A significant point raised is the potential revaluation of gold on July 4, 2026, as indicated by Judy Shelton and mentioned in the "Genius Act." While the exact revalued price is debatable (ranging from market price to James Rickards' prediction of $24,000), the 95% historical correlation between gold and silver is emphasized. Schechman believes gold will not surge without silver following closely, and silver will likely outperform gold on a percentage basis.

He also touches on the return of silver to the US, suggesting it's not due to tariffs but rather a reshoring effort to cover massive short positions and avoid paying tariffs. This move is seen as giving the LBMA a temporary reprieve. He points to the backwardation in silver trading on Friday and the imbalance between daily trading volume and the available physical float.

Technical Analysis and Price Targets

Schechman discusses technical analysis, referencing the cup and handle formation in silver's chart. He notes that breaking through the $50 resistance level signifies breaking through the "cup" and the subsequent "handle." Measuring this formation, from the 1980 peak to the early 1990s bottom ($4-$50), suggests a potential target of $96. He also mentions the 42:1 gold-silver ratio, which has been the average for the past 200 years, further supporting the idea that $100 silver is not out of line. He also brings up the geologic ratio of 7:1, which, if applied to the current gold price, would imply silver should be around $570.

The Curse and Blessing of Visionary Leadership

Schechman reflects on the "curse and blessing" of being a CEO, which involves being a visionary looking far ahead. He uses a skiing metaphor, emphasizing the need to look ahead rather than at the immediate tips of the skis. He believes it's better to be early than late, even if accused of being so. He connects the dots based on his observations and presents logical outcomes, even if they are risky to state publicly. He sees the "Genius Act" as creating a new monetary system and government actions securing basic commodity metals as strategic, indicating a move away from a debt-based system towards one based on tangible assets.

Preparedness and Government Intervention

The concept of preparedness is echoed by Rick Rule's sentiment: "I'd rather be seven years early than one day late." The question of whether governments will restrict private ownership of silver due to its importance for power and military needs is raised. Schechman hopes not, but suggests that a more likely scenario might involve nationalizing ETFs like SLV, which hold vast amounts of silver but do not allow physical delivery for most investors. He points to JP Morgan's history of market manipulation and their control over large silver stockpiles. He believes nationalizing assets from one's own citizens would be a line that is "almost impossible to come back from" in terms of trust, especially when other countries are promoting metal ownership.

Platinum's Potential

Regarding platinum, Schechman believes its price should return to its historic norm of being equal to or greater than gold's price, especially considering gold's potential revaluation. He highlights the geologic anomaly where platinum is significantly rarer than gold. He notes the supply constraints, including the US Mint's lack of platinum eagle production for several years. While gold and silver are viewed strategically and monetarily, he is unsure of the US government's view on platinum, but argues that all elements that could be viewed as strategic will likely see increased demand.

Government Aid in Mining and Mining Stocks

The discussion turns to government involvement in mining critical materials. Schechman confirms that governments will likely fast-track mining permits and aid in mining endeavors for critical elements. He points out that the US is currently subservient to countries like Peru, Mexico, and Canada for silver imports, making self-sufficiency crucial. He mentions examples like Guardian Metal Resources (tungsten) and Argenta Silver, which have received government support and fast-tracked permits.

For gold and silver mining stocks, Schechman recommends First Majestic as a pure silver play. He also suggests royalty companies like Franco Nevada, Royal Gold, and Silver Wheaton. He advises starting with the majors, as a small allocation of institutional money into mining shares would likely flow to them first. He also mentions contacting Sprat USA in Carlsbad, California, for industry connections.

Fiat Currency Inflation and Precious Metals

The "crushing weight of inflation in fiat currency" is addressed, with Schechman agreeing that it's becoming existential for many. He sees a move from fiat towards precious metals-based currency, noting that 11 states are already allowing or moving towards legal tender status for metals. He suggests that individuals can become their "own bank" by holding gold and silver. He contrasts the dollar's performance against other currencies with its performance against silver, which has seen a 70% decline this year. He emphasizes that gold and silver are owned not to become wealthy, but to protect against dollar debasement. He believes this is the only path to economic growth, preventing default or hyperinflation.

Weekly Specials and Market Indicators

The conversation concludes with a review of weekly specials, including:

• Brilliant Uncirculated St. Gaudens $20 gold pieces: Priced at $99 over melt value, which is below spot price given the current gold price of $4,100. This is presented as an excellent value compared to gold eagles and buffaloes selling at $200-$300 over spot.
• 2025 Silver Maple Leafs: Priced at $6.75 over spot, indicating rising premiums and falling availability, reminiscent of the COVID-19 period.
• Palladium: Available for the first time in a while at $199 over spot. Despite its current price being below platinum and gold, it has historically outperformed, and having a few ounces is suggested.

Schechman reiterates that the rising premiums on items like Silver Maple Leafs are a direct result of increasing difficulty in obtaining them and growing public awareness. He concludes by thanking the audience and emphasizing the importance of staying informed through the Liberty and Finance mailing list.