Sen. Thom Tillis on where the U.S. finds itself in war with Iran: "Hard to tell right now"

Key Concepts

• AUMF (Authorization for Use of Military Force): A legislative authorization for the President to use military force, intended to provide legal legitimacy and congressional backing for ongoing operations.
• War Powers Resolution: A federal law intended to check the U.S. President's power to commit the U.S. to an armed conflict without the consent of the U.S. Congress.
• Asymmetrical Warfare: Military tactics used by a weaker force against a stronger one, often involving unconventional methods like drones and intelligence sharing.
• IRGC (Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps): A branch of the Iranian Armed Forces, described as a sophisticated organization utilizing asymmetrical tactics.
• Federal Reserve Independence: The principle that the Fed should make monetary policy decisions without political interference.
• JCPOA (Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action): The 2015 nuclear deal with Iran, from which the U.S. withdrew under the Trump administration.

---

1. Conflict with Iran and Congressional Oversight

Senator Tom Tillis emphasizes that the U.S. is approaching the 60-day mark of hostilities with Iran, a critical threshold under the War Powers Resolution.

• Congressional Role: Tillis argues that the White House must now brief the full membership of Congress, not just committees of jurisdiction, to secure public support for the mission.
• Strategic Objectives: He insists that any AUMF must be predicated on clearly defined strategic objectives and a specific timeline. Without these, he is hesitant to grant authorization.
• Assessment of Capabilities: Addressing a Defense Intelligence Agency report, Tillis acknowledges that Iran retains significant missile and drone stockpiles despite U.S. efforts. He attributes this to Iran’s "asymmetrical warfare" tactics and intelligence/coaching support from Russia.
• Negotiation Concerns: Tillis expresses skepticism regarding negotiations with the Iranian theocracy, questioning whether the current interlocutors have the authority to "sign on the dotted line" and be held accountable, particularly given the independent power of the IRGC. He asserts that any agreement must be ratified by Congress to avoid the pitfalls of the JCPOA.

2. Federal Reserve and the Kevin Warsh Nomination

Tillis is currently blocking the confirmation of Kevin Warsh to the Federal Reserve, citing concerns over a Department of Justice (DOJ) investigation into building renovations at the Fed.

• The Investigation: Tillis characterizes the DOJ investigation as "weak at best," noting that subpoenas were quashed in court and that committee members found no evidence of criminal activity.
• The "Red Line": He views the independence of the Federal Reserve as a "red line." He argues that the DOJ’s involvement in internal Fed matters threatens the global perception of the U.S. financial system.
• Proposed Solution: Tillis suggests that Congress should take over the investigation to resolve it quickly, allowing the confirmation of Warsh to proceed. He states, "If that investigation is still going on in the 260th day, then I'm pretty certain Kevin Warsh has not been confirmed."

3. Government Shutdown and DHS Funding

Regarding the ongoing partial government shutdown affecting the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), Tillis expresses urgency in resolving the impasse.

• Political Responsibility: Tillis warns that Republicans in the House must recognize that they will "own full responsibility" for the shutdown, especially since the Senate has already shown broad support for a measure to resolve it.
• Operational Impact: He highlights that the shutdown is freezing FEMA grants, public assistance, and depleting disaster assistance accounts.
• Call to Action: He urges his colleagues to prioritize the "good" over the "perfect," stating, "Don't let [the perfect] be the enemy of the good." He advocates for passing the existing legislative vehicle to ensure federal employees receive pay and back pay.

---

Synthesis and Conclusion

Senator Tillis’s positions are defined by a demand for institutional accountability and procedural rigor. Whether regarding military engagement in Iran, the independence of the Federal Reserve, or the resolution of a government shutdown, his approach centers on:

1. Legislative Legitimacy: Requiring clear congressional authorization (AUMF) for military actions and ratification for international agreements.
2. Institutional Integrity: Protecting the Federal Reserve from what he deems unnecessary and politically motivated criminal investigations.
3. Pragmatic Governance: Urging House Republicans to end the shutdown to prevent further damage to federal agencies and disaster relief efforts.

His overarching perspective is that the executive branch must operate within clear, transparent, and legally sound frameworks that respect the oversight role of Congress.