Santacruz Silver Mining (TSXV:SCZ) - 'Undervalued?' Investment Series, with Arturo Préstamo

Key Concepts

• Undervaluation Metrics: EV/EBITDA, Price-to-NAV (Net Asset Value), and EV per ounce of silver equivalent production.
• Operational Normalization: The process of stabilizing production levels and costs following past operational disruptions (e.g., dewatering at Bolivar).
• Business Intelligence (BI) & SAP: Digital tools used for real-time monitoring of mining metrics, energy consumption, and operational efficiency.
• Jurisdictional Risk: The impact of operating in Mexico and Bolivia, and the transition of Bolivia toward a more favorable foreign investment framework.
• Capital Allocation: Strategy focusing on organic growth, debt reduction, and potential future share buybacks.
• Multi-Asset/Multi-Metal Platform: A strategy of diversification to mitigate risk and stabilize cash flow through zinc and silver production.

---

1. Financial Valuation and Market Position

Arturo Presto, CEO of Santa Cruz Silver Mining, argues that the company is significantly undervalued compared to its peers, citing discounts of 40% to 75% across key financial metrics:

• EV to Silver Equivalent Production: Trading at ~$45/oz vs. peer average of ~$180/oz (approx. 75% discount).
• EV to EBITDA: Trading at 6x vs. peer average of 15–20x (approx. 60% discount).
• Price to NAV: Trading at 0.4x vs. peer average of 0.85x.

Presto attributes this to "temporary and addressable factors" rather than asset quality, specifically citing the company’s short trading history on the NASDAQ and recent water management issues at the Bolivar mine.

2. Operational Turnaround and Normalization

The company is currently executing a "normalization" phase to improve production and margins:

• Simapan (Mexico): Increasing throughput and head grades at level 960. All-in Sustaining Costs (AISC) are expected to decrease as heavy capital expenditure (capex) phases conclude.
• Bolivar (Bolivia): The dewatering process is on track to be completed by the end of Q3, which will restore full production capacity to the high-grade Pumabamba and Nan veins.
• Strategic Growth: The company plans to develop a dedicated milling facility for San Lucas to alleviate pressure on existing mills, aiming to increase overall production efficiency.

3. Management Framework and Technology

Santa Cruz Silver utilizes a "boots on the ground" management style supported by advanced digital infrastructure:

• SAP Integration: Mexico operations have been integrated into the SAP umbrella, ensuring reliable and efficient reporting.
• Business Intelligence (BI): Management uses BI software to monitor live data, including energy usage, miner headcount, development meters, and head grades. The system provides automated alarms when operations deviate from budget or operational targets.

4. Capital Allocation and Funding

• Debt Status: The company has successfully paid off Glencore and is effectively debt-free, excluding local revolving facilities.
• Local Funding: The company successfully issued promissory notes in Bolivia, which were oversubscribed by four times in under 15 minutes. This highlights strong local confidence in the company’s reputation as a major employer and responsible operator.
• Future Strategy: The company plans to transition from promissory notes to a formal bond program (3–7 year terms) to improve treasury efficiency. Future capital will be directed toward the Sorakaya mine (targeting 3 million ounces of silver equivalent by 2027) and potential share buybacks if the stock remains undervalued.

5. Jurisdictional and Diversification Perspective

Presto defends the company’s multi-jurisdictional and multi-metal structure as a "platform" rather than a source of complexity:

• Risk Mitigation: Diversification across multiple mines and metals (silver and zinc) provides stability against the volatility of silver prices and localized operational shocks.
• Bolivia Outlook: Presto notes that the current administration is actively improving the legal framework for foreign investment, positioning Bolivia as an increasingly safe and attractive mining jurisdiction.
• Human Capital: The company fosters cross-pollination of expertise, with teams from Mexico and Bolivia sharing technical knowledge and software implementation strategies.

Notable Quotes

• "We’re not undervalued by just 10–20%, but up to 40–50% in some cases." — Arturo Presto, on the company's market valuation.
• "I can see on my phone, literally on a live basis, how each and every mine is doing... the BI system gives you alarms when things go out of budget." — Presto, on the role of technology in management.
• "Being a one-only mine company... that’s a higher risk. Being a multi-metal and multi-jurisdiction company translates into a more solid risk-reward ratio." — Presto, on the company's structural strategy.

Synthesis

Santa Cruz Silver Mining is positioning itself as a disciplined, technology-driven growth company. By focusing on operational efficiency, de-leveraging the balance sheet, and leveraging local capital markets, management aims to close the valuation gap with its peers. The primary catalysts for revaluation include the completion of the Bolivar dewatering process, the graduation to the Toronto Stock Exchange, and the realization of organic growth projects like Sorakaya.