REITs & REAL ESTATE INVESTING 2026
By Value Investing with Sven Carlin, Ph.D.
REITs, Real Estate & Investing in 2026
Key Concepts:
- REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts): Companies that own or finance income-producing real estate across a range of property sectors.
- Dividend Yield: Financial ratio indicating the percentage of a company’s share price that it pays out in dividends annually.
- External Growth: Growth achieved through acquisitions or new developments rather than organic expansion.
- Wealth Effect: The tendency of individuals to increase their spending as the value of their assets rises.
- Money Illusion: The tendency to think of money in nominal terms rather than real terms (adjusted for inflation).
- Fixed-Rate Mortgage: A loan where the interest rate remains constant throughout the loan term.
I. Current State of REITs & Real Estate (2024/2026 Outlook)
The speaker notes a significant decrease in discussion surrounding REIT and real estate investments compared to 2021, attributing this to perceived underperformance – a “dead money” sentiment – in a sluggish market. This presents a potential opportunity for investors. While rising treasury yields are generally negative for REITs (declining interest rates are positive), commercial real estate prices have experienced a substantial decline, nearing levels seen during the 2008 financial crisis. This necessitates caution. Home prices, however, have not declined.
II. Concerns Regarding REIT Value Creation
Over the past decade, the speaker has observed a pattern with REITs: consistent share issuance and promotion of “great deals” without demonstrable value creation. Using Welltower (a Vanguard REIT key company) as a case study, the speaker highlights a disconnect between positive presentation (“unprecedented external growth,” “industry-leading results”) and a declining dividend yield (currently 1.5%).
The speaker points out that Welltower’s growth stagnated after 2015 despite announcing $23 billion in transactions, while the total number of shares outstanding increased tenfold. This illustrates a reliance on issuing shares for capital rather than genuine operational improvement. This pattern is not unique to Welltower, but is observed across various REIT sectors. The speaker argues that this constant share dilution diminishes returns for existing shareholders.
III. Competitive Landscape & Return Limitations
A key argument is that REITs face intense competition from private equity and private capital, particularly in a low-interest-rate environment. This competition limits potential returns because the inherent advantage of owning “just buildings” is eroded. The speaker asserts that truly advantageous REIT investments require a crisis to acquire properties at favorable prices.
IV. Real Estate Investing – Interest Rates & Global Variations
The speaker discusses the impact of rising interest rates on real estate investing, noting that mortgage rates have nearly doubled compared to the late 2010s, when a long-term fixed-rate mortgage was considered a prime investment.
Governments may be incentivized to maintain high home prices to foster the “wealth effect” and encourage consumer spending (the “money illusion”). However, opportunities may exist in specific markets like Italy, where fixed rates remain relatively low, though demographic challenges exist there.
V. Renting vs. Owning – A European Perspective
The speaker contrasts the current real estate market with the situation in 2015 in the Netherlands, where a mortgage of €1,300 could yield a rental income exceeding €2,000, creating a significant cash flow. This is no longer the case.
Given the inflationary environment, particularly in Europe, the speaker advocates for homeownership, settling mortgage debt, and then investing remaining capital. Renting is presented as a perpetually recurring expense. The speaker emphasizes the importance of property location and potential for refurbishment, particularly for individuals with renovation skills (specifically mentioning those from Eastern Europe).
VI. Personal Investment Strategy & Sector Valuation
The speaker explicitly states they are not currently looking to invest in real estate, despite reports of potential 9% yields in Italy. They prefer to allocate capital to their businesses and stocks.
The overall assessment of the REIT sector is that it is currently overvalued and faces too much competition, making it unattractive.
Notable Quotes:
- “They’re always issuing shares…there is no true value created.” – Regarding the pattern observed in REIT operations.
- “You own your own house, you settle that and then what's left, you invest.” – Advocating for homeownership in an inflationary environment.
- “The read sector overvalued, too much competition, therefore again not attractive.” – Summarizing the speaker’s current view on REITs.
Technical Terms:
- External Growth: Expansion achieved through mergers, acquisitions, or new developments, as opposed to organic growth from existing operations.
- Share Dilution: The reduction in existing shareholders' ownership percentage of a company due to the issuance of new shares.
- Nominal vs. Real Terms: Nominal values are expressed in current dollars, while real values are adjusted for inflation.
Logical Connections:
The video progresses logically from a broad overview of the REIT and real estate market to a detailed critique of REIT value creation, a discussion of interest rate impacts, and finally, a personal investment strategy. The speaker connects the macroeconomic environment (interest rates, inflation) to specific investment opportunities and risks.
Data & Statistics:
- Dividend Yield of Welltower: 1.5% (current).
- Welltower Share Issuance: Total shares outstanding increased by a factor of 10.
- Mortgage Rate Increase: Mortgage rates have nearly doubled since the late 2010s.
- Dutch Real Estate Example (2015): Mortgage of €1,300 vs. potential rent of >€2,000.
Conclusion:
The speaker presents a cautious outlook on REITs and real estate investing in the current environment. They argue that the sector is overvalued, faces intense competition, and often relies on share dilution rather than genuine value creation. While acknowledging potential opportunities in specific markets (like Italy), they prioritize alternative investments (businesses and stocks) and advocate for homeownership as a hedge against inflation, particularly in Europe. The core takeaway is to exercise caution, conduct thorough due diligence, and consider personal financial circumstances before investing in REITs or real estate.
Chat with this Video
AI-PoweredHi! I can answer questions about this video "REITs & REAL ESTATE INVESTING 2026". What would you like to know?