Powell receives an 'A' grade for handling politics as Fed chair, says Jefferies' Richard Fisher

Key Concepts

• Federal Reserve Independence: The institutional autonomy of the Fed to make monetary policy decisions free from political pressure.
• "Transitory" Inflation: The Fed’s initial, widely criticized characterization of post-pandemic inflation as temporary.
• Political Intrusion: Historical and contemporary attempts by U.S. Presidents to influence Fed interest rate policy.
• Trimmed Mean: A statistical measure used to gauge underlying inflation by removing extreme outliers (e.g., Cleveland Fed Trimmed Mean).
• Monetary Policy Legacy: The long-term historical assessment of a Fed Chair’s tenure, specifically regarding inflation control.

---

1. Evaluation of Chair Jerome Powell’s Performance

Richard Fisher, former Dallas Fed President, evaluates Chair Jerome Powell’s tenure with an "A-" grade.

• Strengths: Fisher highlights Powell’s ability to maintain institutional dignity and resist political interference. He specifically praises Powell’s communication style and his public defense of the Fed’s independence.
• Weaknesses: Fisher acknowledges the "transitory" inflation miscalculation as a significant error. He notes that he personally disagreed with the "transitory" narrative at the time, stating, "I’m transitory, you’re transitory... I don’t buy that argument." However, he credits Powell for acknowledging the mistake and aggressively correcting course through subsequent rate hikes.

2. Historical Context of Political Pressure

Fisher provides historical precedents to illustrate the difficulty of maintaining Fed independence against aggressive executive branch pressure:

• William McChesney Martin & Harry Truman (1951): Truman pressured Martin to cut rates; when Martin refused, Truman publicly labeled him a "traitor."
• William McChesney Martin & Lyndon B. Johnson: Johnson famously took Martin to his ranch and physically intimidated him into cutting rates to fund the Vietnam War. Martin later expressed deep regret, believing this capitulation helped trigger the "Great Inflation" of the 1970s.
• The "Third Chair" Perspective: Fisher argues that Powell is the third major historical figure to face such intense political scrutiny, and he has handled it with more resilience than some predecessors.

3. Strategic Role and Legacy

Fisher offers a unique perspective on why Powell remains in his position:

• Providing "Cover": Fisher suggests that by staying on, Powell provides a protective buffer for Kevin Warsh. Warsh will likely face immense political pressure to cut interest rates, and Powell’s presence allows him to absorb the "heat" from the White House.
• Avoiding Past Mistakes: Fisher warns against relying too heavily on simplified metrics like the "Cleveland Trimmed Mean." He references Arthur Burns, who reduced policy to too few variables, ultimately leading to the Great Inflation. He cautions that Warsh must consider his long-term legacy, as he is only 55 and has a long career ahead of him.

4. Key Arguments and Perspectives

• The Noble Resistance: Fisher argues that it is "noble" for Powell to continue taking political heat to protect the integrity of the Federal Reserve’s decision-making process.
• Policy Outlook: Fisher suggests that the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) is unlikely to move rates in the immediate upcoming meetings, noting that some members are even considering rate increases rather than cuts, despite political pressure to the contrary.

5. Notable Quotes

• "He [Powell] has fended off the intrusion of the political authorities into the business of the Fed." — Richard Fisher, on Powell’s political resilience.
• "Martin confided to his friends he was going to his deathbed ashamed of himself, and he felt he started the Great Inflation." — Fisher, regarding the dangers of succumbing to political pressure.
• "I think it’s pretty noble of him [Powell] to take that heat." — Fisher, on Powell’s role in shielding the Fed from political fallout.

---

Synthesis and Conclusion

The main takeaway is that Chair Jerome Powell’s legacy is defined by a tension between his early policy errors regarding inflation and his successful defense of the Federal Reserve’s independence. Richard Fisher emphasizes that while the "transitory" inflation call was a legitimate failure, Powell’s ability to withstand intense political pressure—a challenge that historically broke previous Chairs—is his most significant contribution. By staying in his role, Powell is strategically shielding the institution and his successor from political volatility, prioritizing long-term economic stability over short-term political appeasement.