'Peaky Blinders' star Joe Cole and director Clio Barnard on class, masculinity and modern Britain

Key Concepts

• Social Mobility: The ability of individuals to move between social strata, often associated with financial success and leaving one's roots.
• Toxic Masculinity: Cultural norms that pressure men to suppress emotions, prioritize toughness, and avoid vulnerability.
• Class Inequality: The systemic disparity in the perceived value of lives based on socioeconomic status.
• Emotional Isolation: The modern phenomenon of feeling disconnected despite being hyper-connected via technology.
• Authentic Filmmaking: A methodology prioritizing community immersion and naturalistic performance over traditional, rigid set structures.

---

1. Main Topics and Key Points

The interview focuses on the film I C Buildings Fall Like Lightning, directed by Clio Barnard and starring Joe Cole. The film explores the intersection of class, masculinity, and the disillusionment of young people in Birmingham, UK.

• The Birmingham Context: The film aims to provide an authentic portrayal of Birmingham, moving beyond the limited representation seen in shows like Peaky Blinders.
• The "Success" Paradox: The film examines the character Ryan (played by Joe Cole), who achieves financial success and leaves his hometown, only to find himself isolated and unfulfilled. This reflects a broader societal issue where wealth does not equate to happiness or community belonging.
• Class Value: A central argument in the film is that working-class lives are increasingly undervalued in contemporary Britain, a situation the creators believe is worsening due to the cost-of-living and housing crises.

2. Real-World Applications and Methodology

• Community Immersion: To capture the essence of Birmingham, the production team utilized a local social club, "The Crown," as a central hub. This space served as a rehearsal room, a filming location, an open casting site, and a communal dining area, fostering a genuine connection with the local community.
• Directorial Approach: Clio Barnard employs a fluid, non-intrusive filming style. Joe Cole notes that there is no traditional "Action" or "Cut" called on set; the scenes are allowed to evolve naturally, which helps actors feel relaxed and perform with greater spontaneity.

3. Perspectives on Masculinity

• Emotional Vulnerability: Joe Cole, known for playing "tough" characters in Skins, Peaky Blinders, and Gangs of London, argues that he is drawn to roles that possess "shade, light, and gray areas." He emphasizes that even the toughest characters require human elements and vulnerability.
• Male Communication: Clio Barnard highlights that while the men in the film share deep, intimate bonds, they lack the vocabulary to express their feelings directly. Instead, they communicate through shared activities like music, football, or creating playlists, reflecting a societal lack of healthy male role models.

4. Notable Quotes

• Clio Barnard on the novel’s intent: "I really loved the precision of the political intent of the novel and how that was told through people."
• Joe Cole on his character’s arc: "He represents somebody who's socially mobile and trying to leave where he's from... but ultimately he hasn't found happiness and he hasn't found the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow."
• Joe Cole on the nature of modern loneliness: "We live in a world where we are kind of isolated. We're all attached to our phones and we're all kind of living behind screens and more lonely than perhaps any other generation."

5. Synthesis and Conclusion

The film I C Buildings Fall Like Lightning serves as a social commentary on the "quiet collapse" of dreams for the younger generation. By focusing on the lives of five friends in Birmingham, the film addresses the tension between the desire for social mobility and the need for community. Both Barnard and Cole emphasize that the film is not intended to be a didactic lecture, but rather a way to "shed a light" on the struggles of the working class and the emotional repression often forced upon men. The ultimate takeaway is a call for reflection on the current economic and social climate, hoping to spark a dialogue about the value of human connection over material success.