‘Our allies have been kicking our b*tts for centuries’: Elfreth 'EXPOSES' Navy shipbuilding crisis

Key Concepts

• Industrial Base Revitalization: Efforts to supercharge domestic shipbuilding and maintenance capacity.
• LSM (Landing Ship Medium): A critical vessel for littoral maneuver, designed for shore-to-shore operations in the Indo-Pacific.
• Trust but Verify: A legislative framework for oversight regarding the temporary use of foreign shipyards while domestic capacity is scaled.
• Amphibious Ready Group/Marine Expeditionary Unit (ARG/MEU): The core naval-marine force structure, with a target of 3.0 presence.
• Littoral Maneuver Bridging Strategy: Interim solutions to maintain operational capability while awaiting new vessel construction.
• Forward Deployment: The strategic importance of Guam for submarine operations and disaster relief.

---

1. Industrial Base and Shipbuilding Strategy

The subcommittee emphasized the urgent need to expand the U.S. industrial base to meet shipbuilding and maintenance requirements.

• Domestic Capacity vs. Foreign Assistance: A central tension exists regarding the proposal to utilize foreign shipyards to address current capacity shortfalls. Legislators expressed skepticism, demanding a "trust but verify" approach to ensure that foreign outsourcing is a temporary bridge rather than a permanent shift.
• The "Two-Part" Proposal: The Navy/Marine Corps representatives proposed a linked strategy: utilizing foreign shipyards to meet immediate needs while simultaneously investing in domestic infrastructure. They suggested a "two, three, or four-fold" investment in U.S. facilities for every dollar spent abroad.
• Infrastructure Development: A specific example was provided regarding the transfer of 435 acres of a former Army Depot in Baltimore to a state economic development corporation, intended to serve as a potential site for industrial expansion and shipbuilding support.

2. LSM and Amphibious Strategy

General Austin highlighted the Landing Ship Medium (LSM) as a cornerstone of the Marine Corps' littoral strategy.

• Operational Utility: Unlike larger vessels, the LSM provides a "small signature, light footprint" capability, allowing for shore-to-shore mobility in the Indo-Pacific. It complements the Marine Air Wing by moving equipment that aircraft cannot transport.
• Budgetary Concerns: Legislators raised concerns regarding the LSM funding being placed in the "mandatory" portion of the budget request. The Marine Corps clarified that they view the budget as a single, unified requirement and emphasized that they are in the final stages of contracting a "vessel construction manager" to initiate the program.
• Bridging Strategy: To address current gaps, the Navy is utilizing TEPFs (Tactical Expeditionary Platform Funds) and other contract solutions. However, officials noted these are "peer-to-peer" (open water) rather than "beach-to-beach" (littoral) capabilities, underscoring the necessity of the LSM.

3. Pacific Posture and Guam Operations

The discussion highlighted the strategic importance of Guam as a forward-deployed hub.

• Disaster Relief: The 11th MEU’s response to a typhoon in Guam and the Northern Marianas served as a case study for the "multi-purpose applicability" of the ARG/MEU structure, demonstrating the ability to pivot from combat readiness to humanitarian assistance.
• Submarine Maintenance: Admiral representatives noted that Guam’s geography allows for immediate access to deep water, making it an ideal submarine base.
• Tender Support: The use of submarine tenders is vital for the "expeditionary nature" of the fleet, allowing for the rearming and resupply of both submarines and surface ships throughout the Area of Responsibility (AOR). Ongoing investments at Polaris Point are prioritized to ensure long-term maintenance viability.

4. Notable Statements

• On Oversight: "Our job is to trust but verify. So, how would you advise us to holding your feet to the fire that those jobs are going to come back?" — Congresswoman regarding the outsourcing of shipbuilding.
• On Strategic Necessity: "LSM plays an essential role in the littoral... it enables us to have the mobility and maneuver and move forces, small signature, light footprint in ways and complement the Marine Air Wing." — General Austin.

---

Synthesis and Conclusion

The hearing underscored a critical transition period for the U.S. Navy and Marine Corps. The primary takeaway is the tension between the immediate need for naval capacity—which may require temporary reliance on foreign partners—and the long-term legislative mandate to revitalize the domestic industrial base. The success of the current strategy hinges on the successful deployment of the LSM program and the ability of the Department of the Navy to prove that foreign investments are directly linked to a proportional, verifiable expansion of U.S. shipbuilding infrastructure. Furthermore, the continued focus on Guam as a forward-deployed hub remains a non-negotiable element of the Pacific defense posture.