Optimistic on the U.S. Economy | Claudia Sahm and Jimmy Connor

Key Concepts

• Whiplash Economy: A term describing an economy hit by a rapid succession of supply shocks (pandemic, energy crises, trade wars, immigration shifts, and AI integration).
• Sahm Rule: A recession indicator developed by Claudia Sahm that triggers when the three-month moving average of the national unemployment rate rises by 0.5 percentage points or more relative to its low over the previous 12 months.
• Dual Mandate: The Federal Reserve’s responsibility to promote maximum employment and stable prices.
• Supply Shocks: External events (e.g., geopolitical conflict, tariffs) that disrupt production and supply chains, often creating tension between the Fed’s inflation and growth goals.
• Fiscal Dominance/Independence: The tension between political pressure (e.g., White House demands for rate cuts) and the Fed’s mandate to manage monetary policy independently.

---

1. Assessment of the US Economy

Claudia Sahm maintains a cautiously bullish outlook on the US economy, citing the resilience of the American consumer and a strong labor market. However, she warns that the economy is experiencing "wear and tear" due to persistent policy uncertainty and a series of global supply shocks.

• Key Data: CPI is at 3.5% annualized; Q1 GDP is at 2% annualized.
• Inflation: The US has experienced five consecutive years of inflation above the Fed’s 2% target. While it has cooled from the 9% peak in 2022, it remains elevated, creating a "sour note" for the current Fed leadership.

2. The Federal Reserve and Monetary Policy

The Fed is currently in a "wait and see" holding pattern.

• Policy Stance: The Fed is prioritizing risk management. They are waiting for evidence that tariff-related price adjustments are rolling off and monitoring energy price spillovers.
• The "Next Move" Debate: While the official stance remains that the next move is likely a rate cut, a growing contingent of Fed members is signaling that a rate hike could be a possibility if inflation remains sticky.
• Leadership Transition: Kevin Warsh is expected to take over as Fed Chair in June. Sahm notes that the Fed is not currently positioned for rate cuts, and the institution remains deliberative rather than fast-moving.
• Powell’s Legacy: Jerome Powell’s decision to remain on the Board of Governors after his term as Chair ends is viewed as a patriotic move to protect the institution’s independence against political pressure, similar to Marriner Eccles in 1948.

3. Labor Market Dynamics

The labor market is described as "bifurcated" and unusual:

• Low Hire/Low Fire: Hiring rates are low, but layoff rates are also historically low. This creates a "vulnerable" environment where a sudden increase in layoffs could spike unemployment quickly.
• Immigration Impact: A sharp decline in net immigration, combined with an aging population, has caused labor supply growth to vanish. This explains why monthly payroll numbers often appear weak (near zero) without signaling a recession.
• Sahm Rule Status: The Sahm Rule triggered in the summer of 2024 due to a 0.5% rise in unemployment. However, Sahm argues this was a "false positive" caused by shifts in labor supply and immigration rather than a traditional demand-driven recession.

4. Energy and Geopolitical Risks

• Consumer Impact: Rising gasoline prices act as a "downdraft" on disposable income. While current levels are not catastrophic, they are politically sensitive and force consumers to cut back on discretionary spending.
• Insulation: The US is more insulated than peer nations due to its status as a major energy producer, which provides a buffer for the broader economy, even if individual consumers feel the pain at the pump.

5. Federal Debt and Fiscal Sustainability

Sahm shares concerns regarding federal debt levels but emphasizes a "bottom-up" approach to the problem:

• Entitlement Reform: She argues that debt sustainability cannot be achieved through discretionary spending cuts alone. The core issue lies in entitlement programs (Social Security, Medicare) which are growing due to an aging population.
• Political Difficulty: While the economic fixes for these programs are straightforward, the political path is "immensely difficult," likely requiring a crisis to force legislative action.

Synthesis and Conclusion

The US economy is currently navigating a "whiplash" environment characterized by high-frequency supply shocks. While the fundamental data—consumer spending and labor market stability—remains positive, the primary risks are institutional. Sahm concludes that while she is optimistic about the long-term trajectory (partly due to AI-driven productivity), she is deeply concerned about the erosion of institutional norms and the political pressure being placed on the Federal Reserve. The "verdict" on whether the Fed’s soft-landing strategy was the correct choice remains to be seen, but the economy has thus far successfully avoided a recession despite significant headwinds.