'Only after DEMILITARIZATION OF HAMAS…': Rubio fires back as DeLauro accuses Trump of failing Gaza

Key Concepts

• Gaza 20-Point Peace Plan: A U.S.-led framework for stabilization, reconstruction, and economic development in Gaza.
• Demilitarization of Hamas: A prerequisite cited by the administration for full implementation of the peace plan and international investment.
• Ebola Response: An inter-agency effort to manage an outbreak in a conflict-ridden region, involving the State Department and Department of Defense.
• Humanitarian Assistance: The debate over U.S. funding levels versus the efficacy of global health programs and the impact of USAID restructuring.
• West Bank Annexation: Concerns regarding settler violence, the demolition of Palestinian villages (e.g., Khan al-Ahmar), and the E1 corridor development.

---

1. The Gaza Crisis and the 20-Point Peace Plan

The discussion centered on the perceived failure of the Trump administration’s 20-point peace plan, which has remained largely unfulfilled eight months after its inception.

• Status of Implementation: The Secretary noted that only two points have been implemented (related to hostage releases). He argued that full implementation is contingent upon the demilitarization of Hamas, which he claims is a prerequisite for international donors to fund reconstruction.
• IDF Directive: The Secretary addressed reports of the IDF seizing 70% of Gaza, stating that such actions are not part of the U.S. peace plan and that the administration’s goal remains a technocratic, non-Hamas Palestinian government.
• Humanitarian Conditions: The ranking member highlighted that 73,000 people have died, and survivors face disease and overcrowding. The Secretary countered that the U.S. has already provided hundreds of millions of dollars in aid through the World Food Program.

2. West Bank Stability and Settler Violence

The ranking member raised concerns regarding the "de facto annexation" of the West Bank, citing:

• Settler Violence: Documented incidents averaging six attacks per day, including arson against mosques and homes.
• E1 Corridor: Plans to demolish the community of Khan al-Ahmar to build settlements, which critics argue would bisect the West Bank and prevent a viable two-state solution.
• Administration Stance: The Secretary stated that the President opposes changes to the status quo in the West Bank, noting that such actions complicate the broader peace deal.

3. Global Health and Ebola Response

The hearing addressed the U.S. response to an Ebola outbreak in a war-torn region, specifically criticizing the lack of a centralized "lead" official.

• Methodology: The response is currently an inter-agency process involving the State Department and the Department of Defense. A key component is an observation post in Kenya to monitor exposed individuals for a 21-day incubation period.
• Leadership Critique: The ranking member argued that the lack of a single designated coordinator (an "Ebola Czar") is "inexcusable," referencing the Secretary’s own 2014 op-ed. The Secretary responded that the administration is considering appointing a full-time coordinator.
• Funding and USAID: The ranking member claimed that the dismantling of USAID and withdrawal from the WHO led to over 500,000 additional child deaths globally due to preventable diseases like diarrhea and malnutrition. The Secretary disputed these figures, asserting that the U.S. spends more on humanitarian aid than the next three or four countries combined and that the issue lies in the lack of global burden-sharing.

---

Notable Quotes

• Secretary: "No one's going to invest money in Hamas in Gaza until Hamas is demilitarized because they know there's going to be another war."
• Ranking Member: "In the wake of withdrawing from World Health and dismantling of USAID, I think it has put us in a position of really trying to play catchup."
• Secretary: "No country in the world spends more money... than the United States does on humanitarian assistance. It's not even close."

---

Synthesis and Conclusion

The exchange highlights a fundamental disagreement between the administration and the ranking member regarding the efficacy of current U.S. foreign policy. The administration maintains that its "20-point plan" is a viable framework hindered primarily by Hamas's refusal to demilitarize and a lack of international financial support. Conversely, the ranking member argues that the administration’s restructuring of global health agencies and its perceived passivity toward Israeli settlement expansion in the West Bank have created a humanitarian crisis and undermined long-term regional stability. The session concluded with a commitment to submit further documentation regarding child mortality statistics to the official record.