McDonald's Beat Earnings and Reversed Hard. Tony Battista Is Catching the Falling Knife.

Key Concepts

• Jade Lizard: An options trading strategy consisting of a short put and a short call spread, designed to be neutral-to-bullish with no upside risk.
• Delta: A measure of an option's price sensitivity to changes in the underlying stock price.
• Probability of Profit (POP): The statistical likelihood that a trade will be profitable at expiration.
• Buying Power: The amount of capital required by a brokerage to maintain a specific position.
• Liquidity/Wide Markets: Refers to the bid-ask spread; wide markets indicate lower liquidity, necessitating disciplined entry pricing.

---

Trade Analysis: McDonald’s (MCD) Post-Earnings

Following McDonald’s earnings report, the stock experienced volatility, initially trading up to $291 before pulling back to the $282–$283 range. The presenter identifies this as a "falling knife" scenario—attempting to buy into a stock that is currently trending downward.

The Strategy: Jade Lizard

To capitalize on a slightly bullish outlook while managing risk, the presenter employs a Jade Lizard strategy. This involves:

1. Short Call Spread: Selling the $290/$295 call spread.
   • Mechanics: The spread is $5 wide. The goal is to collect a credit equal to approximately one-third of the width of the strikes (roughly $1.66), which historically yields a 65–67% probability of success.
2. Short Put: Selling the $275 put.
   • Rationale: Because the call spread creates 10 short deltas (bearish exposure), the presenter sells the $275 put to create 20+ long deltas, resulting in a net bullish position.

Execution and Risk Management

• Entry Discipline: The presenter emphasizes that "entry is king." Because the bid-ask spreads are wide ($4.25–$4.75), traders must set a specific price and wait for a fill rather than chasing the stock as it moves.
• Performance Metrics:
  • Credit Received: The presenter was filled at $5.55, though the market price later moved to $5.85.
  • Buying Power: The trade requires approximately $5,000 in buying power.
  • Probability: The trade carries a 75% probability of profit.
• Risk Profile:
  • Upside: There is no risk to the upside due to the call spread structure.
  • Downside: The primary risk exists if the stock drops below $270, a price level the presenter notes McDonald’s has not reached in several years.

Key Arguments and Perspectives

• Market Liquidity: The presenter warns against market volatility and wide spreads, advising traders to "go in small" and maintain patience.
• Delta Balancing: A core argument is that when selling a call spread to generate income, one must offset the short deltas with a larger put position if the overall goal is to remain bullish.
• Strategic Patience: The presenter highlights the importance of not letting the stock's movement dictate a change in entry price, reinforcing that disciplined limit orders are essential in less liquid markets.

Synthesis

The McDonald’s trade serves as a practical application of the Jade Lizard strategy in a post-earnings environment. By balancing a short call spread with a short put, the trader creates a high-probability, bullish position that eliminates upside risk. The success of this trade relies heavily on disciplined entry pricing to overcome the challenges of wide bid-ask spreads and the inherent risks of trading against a downward price trend.