Josef Schachter Warns: Even Higher Prices At The Pump & 'Tremendous Bargains' in Oil and Gas

Key Concepts

• Geopolitical Risk: The impact of the US-Israel conflict with Iran on global energy infrastructure and supply chains.
• Strategic Petroleum Reserves (SPR): Government-held oil stocks used to mitigate supply shocks.
• Shadow Fleet: Oil tankers operating outside traditional regulatory frameworks, often used by sanctioned nations (e.g., Russia, Iran) to move inventory.
• Backwardation: A market condition where the spot price of a commodity is higher than the price of futures contracts, often signaling immediate supply scarcity.
• Net Asset Value (NAV): A valuation metric used to determine the intrinsic value of energy companies based on reserves and future cash flows.
• Growth Wedge: The necessity for energy companies to maintain a pipeline of new drilling projects to ensure long-term production growth.
• Energy Service Sector: Companies providing the equipment, drilling, and technical services required for oil and gas extraction.

---

1. Impact of Middle East Conflict on Energy Supply

The conflict, which escalated on February 28th, has caused irreparable damage to critical oil and gas infrastructure in the Middle East.

• Supply Disruption: Approximately 14–16 million barrels per day (bpd) are currently restricted from reaching the market. While Saudi Arabia is utilizing pipelines to bypass the Strait of Hormuz, the risk of further Houthi interference remains high.
• Inventory Depletion: The market is currently being cushioned by offshore "shadow fleet" inventories (Russia, Iran, Venezuela). Joseph Shakar warns that once these reserves are exhausted, the supply crisis will intensify significantly.
• Infrastructure Damage: Qatar has lost LNG plants that may take 4–5 years to rebuild. Attacks on desalination plants in the Persian Gulf pose a humanitarian and economic threat, as these nations rely on them for water.

2. Broader Economic Consequences

• Agricultural Impact: The disruption has halted the supply of sulfur, a critical component for fertilizer. This threatens to reduce crop yields in the upcoming fall planting season, potentially driving food inflation.
• Semiconductor Industry: Helium, a byproduct of the region's energy sector, is essential for semiconductor chip manufacturing. Supply shortages here could impact the global tech sector.
• Recession Risk: Shakar suggests that if oil prices reach $130–$140 per barrel, a global recession becomes a distinct possibility. He notes that the consumer is already "tapped out," with evidence of delinquencies in auto loans and declining retail sales.

3. Market Dynamics and Price Forecasts

• WTI vs. Brent: Historically, Brent traded at a premium to WTI. Currently, WTI trades at a premium because US supply is accessible, while Brent-linked supplies are constrained.
• Price Outlook: If the war ends in May, Shakar anticipates an $80–$90 pricing environment for the remainder of the year. If the conflict persists, prices could spike to $150–$180, at which point demand destruction would likely force a market correction.
• Historical Parallels: Shakar compares the current situation to the 1970s oil crisis and the 1990 Iraqi invasion of Kuwait, noting that price spikes eventually subside once supply stabilizes or demand is crushed by economic contraction.

4. Investment Strategy and Sector Analysis

• The "Growth Wedge" Requirement: Shakar argues that the "game has changed" as of March 1st. Companies focused solely on debt repayment are no longer sufficient; investors should prioritize companies with a "growth wedge"—the ability to increase production.
• Preferred Sectors:
  • Natural Gas: Favored due to high liquids content (condensate/propane) which provides cash flow even when gas prices are low.
  • Energy Services: Expected to see increased utilization as producers flush with cash reinvest in drilling.
• Selection Criteria: Shakar emphasizes looking for:
  1. Low finding and development (F&D) costs.
  2. Low operating costs per barrel of oil equivalent (BOE).
  3. Management teams with significant equity stakes.
  4. Companies with large reserve life indices (e.g., Canadian oil sands).

5. Notable Quotes

• "Somebody's got to wake up in the UK Parliament and say, 'We're a bunch of dummies.'" — Regarding the UK's decision to limit domestic North Sea production while importing energy from the Middle East.
• "If I was to use a golf analogy, we're on the fourth hole of a golf course and there's still a lot of golf to play." — Regarding the long-term potential of the oil and gas sector.

Synthesis and Conclusion

The energy landscape has undergone a structural shift due to the destruction of Middle Eastern infrastructure. While short-term volatility is driven by the war, the long-term outlook remains bullish due to the necessity of energy for global development (AI, data centers, and industrial growth). Investors are advised to focus on low-cost, high-reserve operators with strong balance sheets and to view market corrections as buying opportunities, rather than signs of a cycle peak. The transition from debt-focused to growth-focused management is the new benchmark for success in the energy sector.