Israel mourns October 7 victims as Trump’s peace plan talks continue | BBC News

Key Concepts:

• October 7th Attacks: Hamas-led attacks on Israel, resulting in significant casualties and hostage-taking.
• Gaza Campaign: Israel's military response in Gaza, leading to widespread destruction and casualties.
• Indirect Peace Talks: Negotiations in Egypt between Israel and Palestinians, mediated by the US.
• Trump's Peace Plan: A proposed framework to end the conflict, outlining conditions for a ceasefire, hostage release, and aid.
• Nova Festival Site: A location of severe atrocities during the Oct 7th attacks, now a memorial.
• Benjamin Netanyahu: Israeli Prime Minister, facing political pressure regarding security and the war.
• Hamas: Palestinian militant group, significantly reduced but not eliminated, seeking to survive and rebuild.
• West Bank: Palestinian territory, experiencing daily attacks by Jewish settlers, largely excluded from Trump's plan.
• Jewish Settlements: Israeli constructions in the West Bank, considered illegal under international law.
• Humanitarian Crisis in Gaza: Widespread displacement, destruction of homes, and urgent need for aid.
• American Pressure: A crucial factor in bringing parties to the negotiating table and overcoming obstacles.

---

Commemoration of October 7th Attacks and Ongoing Impact

Two years after the Hamas attacks on October 7th, memorial events are taking place in Israel. The attacks resulted in approximately 1,200 people killed and 251 others taken hostage. Of these, 48 are still believed to be in Gaza, with more than half feared dead. In response, Israel launched a military campaign in Gaza, which has led to over 67,000 people killed, according to the Hamas-run Health Ministry.

At the Nova Festival site, a location of immense suffering on October 7th, survivors and rescuers gathered. Ramy, who came to rescue people that day, described the profound pain: "I feel a lot of pain because I saw what happened here. The ground we are standing on held bodies and bodies parts. For me, every tree has a meaning. I know what happened to these trees. I know who was tied to these trees." Hundreds of festival-goers were hunted down, and dozens were taken hostage. The mother of 22-year-old Libby recounted her daughter's last moments, shot in the stomach, then killed while on the phone: "Mommy, they're coming to shoot me again," followed by "we heard the shots that killed her again." Two years on, Libby's mother expressed a lack of safety and a desire for a complete change in leadership: "I think that all the leaders should go. It's like in the computer that you're doing a control delete and you're doing a end task. We should end the this task should be ended."

Political Landscape and Benjamin Netanyahu's Position

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, once known as "Mr. Security," is facing intense pressure to end the war and secure the release of hostages. With elections due next year, his political standing is precarious. While protests demand an end to the conflict, his own voter base holds mixed views on the war. In a Netanyahu stronghold in Jerusalem, residents preparing for the Jewish holiday of Sukkot expressed strong opposition to any plan involving concessions, such as Trump's peace plan: "That is crazy. It's crazy. He'd lose your support. You lose everything." The ongoing war in Gaza continues to echo across Israel, raising questions about whether it can repair the mistakes that led to the October 7th attacks.

Indirect Peace Talks in Egypt and Trump's Plan

Indirect talks between Israel and the Palestinians are underway in Egypt, with a US team en route, aiming to agree upon President Trump's plan to end the war. Trump has stated there is a "really good chance a deal can be agreed." The plan, presented with Israel's Prime Minister Netanyahu and partially agreed by Hamas, outlines several key points, though it is described as a "framework" that is "pretty vague in a lot of places" and lacks "precious little detail."

The proposed framework specifies:

1. Ceasefire: If agreed, Israel will cease all military operations.
2. Hostage Release: Hamas will release all living and dead hostages within 72 hours of the ceasefire.
3. Aid and Redevelopment: Aid will move freely into Gaza, and eventually, redevelopment would begin.

Humanitarian Crisis and Hamas's Status in Gaza

After two years of war, the humanitarian situation in Gaza is dire. The UN estimates that more than 90% of homes are thought to have been damaged or destroyed, displacing hundreds of thousands of people. While Hamas has been "significantly reduced as a fighting force," it has "not been eliminated." Israel does not permit international journalists, including the BBC, to report freely from Gaza.

Hamas marked the anniversary by releasing an AI animation celebrating the October 7th attacks, calling on God to humiliate Israel and claiming to have "shattered the myth of Israeli invincibility." The video also "reincarnates leaders Israel has killed," including Yahi Sinoir, the "chief architect of the 7th of October," who was depicted trying to down an Israeli drone with a stick in his final moments. Hamas asserts that Palestinians "cannot surrender."

On the ground, displaced Gazans like Suede expressed exhaustion and hope for a ceasefire: "We've been under this brutal occupation for nearly two years. We're praying for a ceasefire and for success in the negotiations. People are fed up with this. They are tired of war." Naz, another displaced person, described the constant fear: "I follow the news closely. I tell myself there's progress. Be optimistic. Then when night comes, we have nothing more than increased shelling on the tents of displaced people in the areas they claim are safe."

Hamas continues to exert control, as evidenced by a public execution of men accused of collaborating with Israel a fortnight prior. Hamas also seeks to retain some weapons, fearing revenge attacks, and has been involved in gun battles with rival clans, sometimes leading to Israeli intervention. Halil Abu Shamala, a human rights activist in Gaza, acknowledged Hamas's significant following but believes it's "too late" for them to regain widespread acceptance.

Challenges and Obstacles to Peace

Several major sticking points and risks threaten the success of the peace talks:

• Vagueness of Trump's Plan: The 20-point plan is a framework that requires filling in crucial details such as specific language, maps, timetables, the exchange of hostages for Palestinian prisoners, and the contentious issue of whether Hamas will be allowed to keep any weapons.
• Lack of Trust: There is "zero trust or goodwill" between Israelis and Hamas, making negotiations inherently difficult.
• Netanyahu's Potential Actions: Palestinians fear that Netanyahu could "undermine the talks again" or "reactivate the war" once Israeli captives are returned.
• Withdrawal from Gaza: The plan's specifics regarding Israel's withdrawal from Gaza are unclear, raising concerns about the extent and nature of any pullout.
• West Bank Exclusion: The West Bank, recognized by many as part of Palestine, is not mentioned in Trump's peace plan, raising Palestinian suspicions. This is particularly concerning given that Jewish settlers attack Palestinians almost daily in the West Bank.
• Settlement Expansion: Just outside Jerusalem, Israel has authorized a major expansion of Jewish settlements, which are illegal under international law. The Israeli Prime Minister openly states the purpose is "to stop the creation of a viable and independent Palestine," asserting "this land is ours."

Conclusion and Main Takeaways

The ongoing talks in Egypt represent a critical, albeit fragile, opportunity to end the war in Gaza. The general opinion suggests a "good chance" for a deal, primarily due to President Trump's unprecedented pressure on both Hamas and Benjamin Netanyahu. However, the deep scars of the October 7th attacks, the immense humanitarian crisis in Gaza, and the complex political landscape present formidable obstacles. The vagueness of Trump's 20-point plan, the profound lack of trust between the parties, and contentious issues like Hamas's future and the status of the West Bank and settlements mean that a lasting resolution remains highly challenging. The conflict's endgame in Gaza might be achievable if many obstacles are overcome, but the broader Israeli-Palestinian conflict is expected to continue. As Jeremy Bowen noted, Israel's desire to declare victory and Hamas's aim to survive and rebuild present an "impossible circle to square." Continued American pressure on both sides is deemed crucial for any progress.