Is Colombia heading for its most polarised election yet? | The Economist

Key Concepts

• Total Peace (Paz Total): A government policy aimed at negotiating with various rebel groups and drug trafficking organizations.
• Populism: Political approaches that appeal to the "common people" against perceived elites, often characterized by charismatic leadership and simplified solutions to complex problems.
• Informal Economy: Economic activity that is neither taxed nor monitored by a government.
• Polarization: The divergence of political attitudes to ideological extremes.

---

1. The Political Landscape of Colombia

Colombia is currently facing a highly polarized election cycle with three distinct candidates representing radically different visions for the country. The electorate is divided by a "split picture" of the nation’s current state:

• Security Crisis: The country is experiencing record-high cocaine production (two-thirds of the world's supply) and increased civilian involvement in violence. The government’s "Total Peace" initiative is widely viewed as a failure, as it attempts to negotiate with groups that are primarily drug traffickers.
• Economic Sentiment: Despite security concerns, voters feel more positive about the economy. The current left-wing administration has boosted consumption through a 17% hike in the minimum wage and increased government spending, though critics argue this growth is artificial and driven by pressure on the central bank to lower interest rates.

---

2. Candidate Profiles

Ivan Sepeda (Hard Left)

• Style: Austere, serious, and academic. He avoids the "spectacle" of rallies, preferring to read prepared speeches carefully.
• Platform: He advocates for land distribution, increased welfare spending, and state procurement policies that favor small entities like community kitchens.
• Key Argument: He remains committed to the "Total Peace" policy. He actively attempts to distance himself from the "Venezuela model," seeking to reassure business leaders and markets that he will not lead Colombia toward a socialist dictatorship.

Abalad Espa (Hard Right)

• Style: A "hyperactive performer" who uses spectacle (e.g., tiger costumes, sparks, pumping music) to energize crowds. He is often compared to El Salvador’s Nayib Bukele.
• Platform: Focuses on aggressive security measures, including the construction of 10 privately run "mega-prisons" in the jungle and the implementation of mass trials for gang members. He famously remarked, "Right now, Colombia doesn't have prisons. It has crime universities."
• Controversy: He previously served as legal counsel for Alex Saab, a close ally of Nicolas Maduro accused of money laundering. Espa defends this as a professional duty, using a controversial analogy comparing his role as a lawyer to his personal life to justify the distinction between professional and personal conduct.

Paloma Valencia (Center-Right/Establishment)

• Style: Traditional, sensible, and experienced. She is the granddaughter of a former president and a protégé of Alvaro Uribe.
• Platform: Focuses on security, education, and the informal economy. She represents a platform of "decency and realism."
• Challenges: She is currently trailing in the polls. She expressed frustration at running against populists who "promise more or less anything," noting that her message of hard work and realism is a "tough sell" compared to the populist alternatives.

---

3. Synthesis and Outlook

The election is characterized by a stark choice between ideological extremes. While Paloma Valencia represents the traditional establishment, her struggle to gain traction suggests that the electorate is leaning toward the populist rhetoric of either the hard left (Sepeda) or the hard right (Espa).

Key Takeaway: The most likely outcome is a runoff election between Abalad Espa and Ivan Sepeda. This would present Colombian voters with an extraordinarily polarized choice, forcing them to decide between a radical shift toward state-led welfare and negotiation (Sepeda) or a hardline, populist approach to security and law enforcement (Espa). The current economic "feel-good" factor, driven by government spending, currently favors the left, but the surging popularity of Espa’s security-focused platform indicates a deep-seated public anxiety regarding the country's deteriorating safety.