Illicit tobacco market promotes crime and violence as NSW allocates millions to law enforcement

Key Concepts

• Tobacco Excise: A federal tax levied on tobacco products, which has seen a significant decline in revenue.
• Illicit Tobacco: Unregulated, untaxed tobacco products sold illegally, often linked to organized crime.
• Whack-a-Mole Enforcement: A term used to describe ineffective, repetitive law enforcement efforts where illegal shops reopen immediately after being shut down.
• Fiscal Gap: The discrepancy between projected tax revenue and actual collections due to the rise of the black market.

---

1. The Decline of Tobacco Excise Revenue

The discussion highlights a massive shortfall in federal tobacco excise revenue.

• Financial Figures: The federal government’s prediction for tobacco excise for the current financial year was originally $7.05 billion, but this has been revised downward to $4.13 billion.
• Historical Context: Over the last six years, annual excise revenue has plummeted from approximately $16–$17 billion to roughly $4 billion, representing a loss of $12 billion annually.
• Budgetary Discrepancy: In the October 2022 federal budget, the government projected $13.3 billion in revenue for the current year, a figure that has been missed by a wide margin.

2. Inadequate Federal Response

The guest, Rowan Pike, argues that the federal government’s response to the illicit tobacco crisis is disproportionately small compared to the scale of the financial loss.

• Funding Allocation: The federal government has allocated only $3.5 million per year to combat the illicit tobacco problem.
• The "1/1000th" Argument: Pike notes that this allocation represents only 1/1000th of the annual excise revenue lost, suggesting that the federal government has effectively "given up" on addressing the root cause of the issue.

3. The Burden on State Governments

The illicit tobacco trade has created a public safety crisis that state governments are forced to manage, despite the problem being attributed to federal policy.

• State Frustration: New South Wales (NSW) and other states are pushing back against the federal government, arguing that they are being left to deal with the resulting violence and crime.
• Enforcement Efforts: NSW has invested tens of millions of dollars into increased police resources, stricter laws, and the closure of illegal tobacco shops.
• The "Whack-a-Mole" Phenomenon: Despite these efforts, closed shops frequently reopen, rendering local enforcement ineffective. The consensus among police associations and state premiers is that local enforcement cannot succeed without a change in federal tax policy.

4. Policy Recommendations and Outlook

The core argument presented is that the illicit tobacco market is a direct consequence of current federal tax policies.

• The Link to Criminality: The high tax rate on legal tobacco has created a lucrative black market, fueling organized crime.
• Call for Reform: Experts, including former Border Force officials and police associations, argue that the only way to curb this criminality is to reform the tobacco excise tax.
• Conclusion: Because the federal government failed to address tax reform in the latest budget, the guest concludes that the government has no intention of changing its approach, and consequently, the illicit tobacco crisis is expected to persist.

Synthesis

The illicit tobacco trade in Australia has evolved into a significant fiscal and public safety issue. While the federal government continues to lose billions in projected excise revenue, the burden of managing the resulting criminal activity has fallen on state governments. Despite significant state-level investment in enforcement, the "whack-a-mole" nature of the illicit market persists. The primary takeaway is that without a fundamental shift in federal tax policy, local law enforcement efforts will remain ineffective, and the black market for tobacco will continue to thrive.