Identifying opportunities in AI-related stocks

Key Concepts

• Capital Spending Cycle: The periodic fluctuation in corporate investment in infrastructure and technology.
• Multiple Compression: A scenario where a company's stock price falls relative to its earnings, often due to market sentiment or fear.
• K-Shaped Economy: An economic environment where different sectors or income groups recover or grow at vastly different rates.
• Perpetuity Rates: The assumption that current high growth rates will continue indefinitely.
• High-Quality, Low-Volatility Stocks: Companies with stable earnings, low debt, and consistent dividends that are less sensitive to market swings.

---

1. The AI Spending Cycle and Market Valuation

Chad Morgan, Senior Portfolio Manager at Washington Crossing Advisors, argues that the current AI-driven stock market rally is fueled by a capital spending cycle that will eventually decelerate.

• The "Perpetuity" Fallacy: Morgan notes that many companies currently trade at high Price-to-Earnings (PE) multiples (30x–50x) based on the assumption that AI-driven growth will persist for decades. He contends this is unrealistic, as capital cycles are finite.
• Investment Strategy: As the AI spending wave eventually breaks, opportunities will emerge in "beaten down" software companies and consumer sectors where valuations have become more attractive due to market fear.

2. The State of the American Consumer

Morgan highlights a growing concern regarding the health of the U.S. consumer, characterized by a "K-shaped" consumption pattern.

• Economic Indicators: Rising oil prices are negatively impacting the mid-tier consumer, a trend reflected in recent disappointing earnings reports from companies like Planet Fitness and concerns voiced by McDonald’s and Whirlpool.
• Macro Disconnect: While the broader economy appears healthy due to corporate capital spending, this growth is not effectively trickling down to the average consumer.

3. Federal Reserve and Inflation Outlook

• Stubborn Inflation: Morgan believes the Federal Reserve will remain on hold until the end of the year.
• Shift in Expectations: Earlier market optimism regarding one or two rate cuts has been largely "taken off the table" due to persistently high inflation data.

4. Asset Allocation and Strategic Positioning

Washington Crossing Advisors is currently positioning portfolios with the following strategy:

• Geographic Focus: Underweight U.S. equities; overweight international markets (both developed and emerging).
• Stock/Bond Mix: Overweight U.S. bonds.
• The "Seam of Opportunity": The firm is targeting high-quality, low-volatility companies whose PE multiples have compressed due to the market's obsession with high-volatility AI trades.

5. Case Studies: Opportunities in AI-Resistant or AI-Leveraged Firms

Morgan identifies three specific companies that have seen multiple compression due to irrational fears that AI will render their business models obsolete:

• Moody’s (MCO):
  • Thesis: Despite fears of AI disruption, credit rating agencies remain essential due to regulatory requirements.
  • Strengths: High-margin data services, low debt, and a rising dividend.
• ADP (Automatic Data Processing):
  • Thesis: The stock is down ~25% year-to-date, yet business trends remain strong.
  • Strengths: AI implementation is expected to improve operating margins significantly; the business model is highly compliant and carries low risk of AI displacement.
• IBM:
  • Thesis: IBM provides cost-effective AI solutions to global corporations and is a leader in quantum computing.
  • Growth Target: If IBM achieves 7–9% organic revenue growth (surpassing the 5–6% required to justify current valuations), the stock offers significant capital appreciation potential.

---

Synthesis and Conclusion

The core takeaway from Morgan’s analysis is that the market is currently mispricing companies by either over-extending valuations on AI hype or unfairly punishing established, profitable firms due to a misplaced fear of AI disruption. By focusing on high-quality companies with compressed multiples—such as Moody’s, ADP, and IBM—investors can find value that is currently being overlooked. Furthermore, investors should remain cautious regarding the U.S. consumer and prepare for a "higher-for-longer" interest rate environment as the AI capital spending cycle eventually cools.