How to Trade Broken Wing Butterflies Like a Pro

Key Concepts

• Broken Wing Butterfly: An options strategy where the long options (wings) are not equidistant from the short options, allowing the trader to convert a debit spread into a credit spread.
• Index Options: Cash-settled bets on the movement of an entire index (e.g., S&P 500) rather than individual stocks.
• Delta: A statistical measure representing the probability of an option expiring in-the-money.
• Credit Spread: A strategy where the trader receives a net cash payment (premium) upfront to enter the trade.
• Theta Decay (Time Decay): The rate at which an option loses value as it approaches its expiration date; a key component of profitability for credit-based strategies.
• Batman Trade (Field Goal Strategy): A non-directional strategy combining a call broken wing butterfly and a put broken wing butterfly to profit from the market staying within a specific range.
• Backtesting: The process of testing a trading strategy against historical data to determine its viability and edge.

---

1. Understanding Index Options

Index options are cash-settled instruments that do not involve the delivery of underlying shares.

• Mechanism: A call option pays off if the index expires above the strike price; a put option pays off if it expires below.
• Profit/Loss: Buyers win when the index moves past the strike price by an amount exceeding the premium paid. Sellers (who receive the premium) win when the index fails to reach the strike price or does not move far enough to exceed the cost of the option.

2. The Butterfly Strategy Framework

• Standard Butterfly: Involves selling two at-the-money options and buying one long option above and one below, all equidistant from the center. These are typically "debit spreads," meaning the trader pays to enter.
• Broken Wing Butterfly: By pulling one of the long wings closer to the short strikes, the cost of the long option decreases. This adjustment transforms the trade from a debit spread into a credit spread, allowing the trader to collect cash upfront.

3. Directional Trading with Broken Wing Butterflies

The strategy is used to express a directional view (bullish or bearish) while allowing for "room to be wrong."

• Methodology:
  1. Identify a directional trigger (e.g., RSI overbought/oversold).
  2. Structure the butterfly as a credit spread by adjusting the wing distance.
  3. The "Irony" of Success: If the market moves in the expected direction, the trader profits. However, if the market moves slowly or stays stagnant, the trader can often profit more due to time decay (theta) as the options expire worthless.
• Example: Using RSI at 30 (oversold) to enter a put broken wing butterfly. Even if the market continues to drop slightly, the passage of time causes the options to lose value, potentially resulting in a profit if the trade is closed before expiration.

4. The "Batman" (Field Goal) Strategy

This is a non-directional approach used when there is no clear market bias.

• Structure: Combines a call broken wing butterfly and a put broken wing butterfly.
• Application: The trader collects credits from both sides. The goal is for the market to stay between the "uprights" (the short strikes).
• Risk Management: Because the trade is sold at a credit, the trader keeps the initial cash unless the market moves aggressively beyond the short strikes, necessitating a stop-loss.

5. Key Arguments and Risk Management

• The Importance of Stops: Seth emphasizes that no strategy is right 100% of the time. "The best way to get fired at a prop firm is by not taking your stop."
• Edge: An edge is found by identifying market inefficiencies or using indicators (like RSI) combined with backtested strategies.
• Flexibility: Unlike simple directional stock trades, broken wing butterflies allow traders to remain in a position even if the initial timing is slightly off, provided the market eventually moves in the anticipated direction or time decay works in the trader's favor.
• Backtesting: Traders are encouraged to use software (e.g., Option Net Explorer) to validate hypotheses before committing capital.

6. Synthesis and Conclusion

The broken wing butterfly is a versatile tool that shifts the focus from "being right" to "managing probability and time." By converting debit spreads into credit spreads, traders receive upfront capital and gain a buffer against minor directional errors. Whether used directionally (based on indicators like RSI) or non-directionally (the Batman trade), the strategy relies on the mathematical reality of options expiration and theta decay. Success is not guaranteed by the strategy alone but by disciplined risk management, the use of stop-losses, and rigorous backtesting of the chosen directional triggers.