Do Iranians really want exiled Crown Prince Reza Pahlavi in power? | DW News

Iran Protests & The Role of Reza Pahlavi: A Detailed Analysis

Key Concepts:

• Reza Pahlavi: The current heir to the former Iranian throne, son of the last Shah, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi.
• Islamic Republic: The current political system of Iran, established after the 1979 revolution.
• Iranian Diaspora: Iranians living outside of Iran, often politically active and vocal about Iranian affairs.
• "Woman, Life, Freedom" (زن، زندگی، آزادی): The central slogan of the recent protests sparked by the death of Mahsa Amini.
• Gammon Institute: An Iranian opposition research institution providing statistical data on public opinion.
• Real (Iranian Currency): The official currency of Iran, recently experiencing a significant collapse in value.
• Ayatollah Khomeini: The founder of the Islamic Republic of Iran, returning from exile in 1979.

1. Economic Crisis & Protests:

The report begins by outlining the current unrest in Iran, triggered by a severe economic crisis and the collapse of the Iranian real (currency). Security forces responded to a sit-in at Tehran’s Grand Bazaar with tear gas. Activists report at least 36 deaths resulting from clashes between protesters and security forces. The economic hardship is illustrated by examples: a tray of eggs increasing in price from 2.2 million real to 3.5 million real within a week, and a significant drop in sales for shopkeepers. The protests are fueled by rising prices of essential goods like cooking oil and rice, indicating widespread economic suffering. President’s calls for dialogue have been overshadowed by continued crackdowns by security forces.

2. The Resurgence of Monarchist Sentiment & Reza Pahlavi:

Amidst the protests, chants of “Long live the Shah” have re-emerged, suggesting a renewed interest in the monarchy. This has led to increased attention on Reza Pahlavi, the exiled crown prince. However, the report emphasizes caution regarding the extent of his support within Iran, noting that it is often amplified by the Iranian diaspora – particularly those who are staunch monarchists – and their presence on social media. The report highlights the historical context: the 1979 Iranian Revolution, which overthrew the Pahlavi dynasty and led to the establishment of the Islamic Republic following Ayatollah Khomeini’s return from exile in France.

3. Reza Pahlavi’s Background & Political Activities:

Reza Pahlavi was raised as the heir apparent to his father, Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi. Following the revolution, the Pahlavis were forced into exile. Since then, Reza Pahlavi has actively campaigned against the Islamic Republic, urging Iranians to rise up against the regime and seeking international support. He publicly tweeted to US President Donald Trump, offering a “plan for a stable transition” and seeking US leadership in establishing “lasting peace.” Crucially, he has consistently stated that his goal is not to reclaim the throne but to facilitate a free and fair election where the Iranian people can determine their own future. He states, “My only mission in life is to see to it that the Iranian people can ultimately determine their own future in a free and fair election.”

4. Assessing Reza Pahlavi’s Support Base:

The report presents conflicting assessments of Reza Pahlavi’s popularity. While some monarchists claim support levels of 80-85%, data from the Gammon Institute, an Iranian opposition research institution, suggests approximately 35% support. A key question raised is why, with such a significant level of support, he has not been able to overthrow the Islamic Republic in the past 46 years. This is attributed to his inability to translate support into “political agency” or “political mobilization.” The report also notes that some protesters view him as a potential transitional leader rather than necessarily advocating for a full restoration of the monarchy, highlighting a lack of clear alternatives within the opposition.

5. Expert Analysis: Shahin Madares’ Perspective:

International security analyst Shahin Madares provides a nuanced perspective. He acknowledges that Reza Pahlavi has a following based on “nostalgia” for the pre-revolution era and a belief that the monarchy was not as authoritarian as portrayed. However, he dismisses the 80-85% support claim as “ridiculous.” Madares emphasizes that the current protests differ from previous economic-driven unrest, citing the “Woman, Life, Freedom” movement sparked by the death of Mahsa Amini as a more fundamental challenge to the Islamic Republic. He believes the regime has been able to suppress past economic protests through brutal force, but the current movement targets the core ideology of the Islamic Republic.

6. The Problem of Dual Roles & Future of Iran:

Madares points out a “conflict of interest” in Reza Pahlavi’s attempt to position himself as both a transitional leader and the leader of the monarchist movement. He argues that the future of Iran lies in a “secular democratic future” that is inclusive of all Iranian ethnicities, rather than a return to either the Pahlavi dynasty or the current theocratic regime. He suggests that the key is to move beyond the duality of Pahlavi versus the Ayatollas.

7. Protest Sustainability & Potential Outcomes:

The report questions the long-term sustainability of the protests, suggesting they may eventually run out of steam without a “miraculous” event, such as a situation similar to the recent events in Venezuela. However, it acknowledges the deep-seated dissatisfaction with the Islamic Republic, which is described as “delegitimized” and a “rogue state.” The report highlights the regime’s history of suppressing protests through violence, but also notes the unique character of the current movement, driven by cultural change and challenging the fundamental principles of the Islamic Republic.

8. Logical Connections & Synthesis:

The report logically progresses from outlining the immediate context of the protests to exploring the potential role of a key figure in the opposition, Reza Pahlavi. It then delves into a critical assessment of his support base and the challenges he faces. The expert analysis provides a broader perspective on the nature of the protests and the potential pathways for Iran’s future. The report concludes by acknowledging the uncertainty surrounding the protests’ outcome but emphasizing the deep-seated desire for change within Iranian society.

9. Data & Statistics:

• 36: Estimated number of people killed in clashes between protesters and security forces.
• 2.2 million to 3.5 million real: Increase in the price of a tray of eggs within one week.
• 35%: Estimated support for Reza Pahlavi within Iran, according to the Gammon Institute.
• 46 years: Length of time since the Iranian Revolution and the Pahlavi family’s exile.

Conclusion:

The situation in Iran remains volatile. While Reza Pahlavi has emerged as a prominent figure in the opposition, his actual support base within Iran is debated. The protests, fueled by economic hardship and a broader desire for political and social change, represent a significant challenge to the Islamic Republic. The future of Iran hinges on whether the opposition can overcome internal divisions, mobilize effectively, and present a viable alternative to both the current regime and a simple restoration of the monarchy. The report underscores the complexity of the situation and the need for a nuanced understanding of the various forces at play.