Did Kemi Badenoch turn it around? | BBC Newscast

Key Concepts Conservative Party Conference, Chem Baydon, Stamp Duty Abolition, New Golden Economic Rule, Deficit Reduction, Fiscal Drag, Chinese Spying Case, Devolved Governments, Minimum Service Requirements, Political Noise, Fiscal Conservatism, Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), National Security Adviser.

Chem Baydon's Leadership and Conference Performance

The Conservative Party conference in Manchester saw Chem Baydon deliver her first ever party conference speech as leader, widely regarded as her "best moment" in the role and a "successful conference." After 11 challenging months, the speech was praised for its confident delivery and for "sharpening" what her leadership and a Conservative government under her would stand for. Internally, party members, previously skeptical, expressed being "pleasantly surprised," suggesting her leadership had been "stabilized in an okay place." The speech marked a strategic shift, moving the party's focus from "cultural questions" to more traditional economic issues and border control, as evidenced by her Sunday "warm-up speech." Her delivery was noted for being natural, incorporating laughter and self-deprecation, a contrast to the "jokey, gimmicky" style of Robert Genrich's earlier speech. This personal approach was seen as a "positive and winning effect," aiming to counter personal criticisms she has faced.

Abolition of Stamp Duty Policy

A major policy announcement was the abolition of stamp duty on homes, unveiled dramatically at the end of Baydon's speech.

• Rationale: Described as a "bad tax" and an "unconservative tax," it is argued to hinder social mobility and prevent people from moving house, acting as a "frictional tax." The policy aims to "free up our housing market," increase housing supply, and promote more efficient use of existing housing stock, for instance, by encouraging older people to downsize without penalty. Economists are said to largely agree on its detrimental effects.
• Specific Details and Caveats:
  • The policy would apply to England and Northern Ireland only, as stamp duty is devolved in Scotland and Wales (though the Conservatives would encourage devolved governments to follow suit).
  • It is restricted to UK-based purchasers buying a primary residence, excluding companies and second homes.
  • The biggest caveat is that it requires a Conservative government to win the next general election, which is still "three and a half years away."
  • It's framed as a "statement of values and priorities" rather than an immediate offer.
  • The policy is "intelligible" to the public, and it's specifically targeted at younger voters/non-pensioners to address the party's "massive demographic problem."
  • It would not affect properties already exempt from stamp duty (e.g., those under £125,000).
  • The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) notes that a third of stamp duty revenue comes from properties over £1 million, suggesting the abolition would disproportionately benefit buyers of more expensive homes.
• Implementation Challenges and Cost: The party did not commit to immediate implementation post-election, raising concerns that this could "gum up" the housing market as people delay purchases to save "tens of thousands of pounds." The estimated cost of abolition is around £9 billion.
• Political Framing: The Conservative press release heavily criticizes Shadow Chancellor Rachel Reeves for not planning to increase stamp duty thresholds, arguing this would lead to "fiscal drag" and higher taxes for more people under Labour, thereby providing "sharp definition" for the Conservative stance.

New Golden Economic Rule

Chem Baydon introduced a "new golden economic rule": "Every pound we save will be put to work. At least half will go towards cutting the deficit because living within our means is our first priority."

• Context: This rule is a "retro reference" to Gordon Brown's golden rules and signals a renewed focus on reducing the deficit (the gap between government earnings and spending).
• Mechanism: It means that if the government makes permanent cuts (e.g., to the benefits bill), half of the savings will be dedicated to deficit reduction, while the other half can fund new policies or tax cuts like stamp duty abolition.
• Strategic Positioning: This positions the Conservatives as the party willing to "cut things and bank that," advocating for a "leaner state doing less." This stance aims to differentiate them from Labour, which is seen as "spending more and borrowing more," and from Reform UK, which is perceived as moving in a "statist high-spending direction."
• Deficit Definition: While Rachel Reeves' current plan aims for no deficit on the day-to-day current budget by the end of the parliament, the Conservatives emphasize the broader national debt and associated interest payments.

Chinese Spying Case Controversy

A significant political controversy discussed was the collapse of a Chinese spying case involving two men, Christopher Cash and Christopher Barry, one of whom worked in Parliament.

• Conflicting Accounts:
  • The current Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), Steven Parkinson, stated the case collapsed because the government was unwilling to declare China an "enemy" or "threat" in court, which was deemed necessary for a realistic chance of conviction.
  • Former DPP, Kier Starmer, countered that the relevant test was how China was formally classified by the government during the alleged offenses (2022-2023), when it was not formally classified as a threat.
• Political Fallout: Chem Baydon accused the Labour government of deliberately collapsing the trial to "suck up to Beijing," labeling it "squalid." This comes amidst efforts by the current UK government to warm relations with China, including trade talks and visits by senior ministers.
• Geopolitical Conundrum: The situation highlights the "unavoidable conundrum of the mid-2020s" regarding China's growing economic and geopolitical influence, balancing concerns about espionage with the need for diplomatic and economic engagement. Governments are noted for using carefully chosen language (e.g., "epoch-defining challenge") to avoid formally labeling China an "enemy" due to potential consequences.
• Skepticism and Accountability: Former DPP Lord McDonald and former Attorney General Dominic Grieve suggested the collapse might be a "cockup" or "complete muddle" rather than a conspiracy, questioning why the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) didn't clarify the government's stance earlier. With Parliament resuming, calls for accountability are expected, including an appearance by National Security Adviser Jonathan Powell before MPs.

Other Policy and Strategic Notes

• Strikes: The Conservatives reiterated their intention to ban doctors from striking and to tighten minimum service requirements for other health service staff, citing the impact of recent strikes on patient care.
• Education: They proposed more funding for apprenticeships and less for universities.
• Reform UK: Strategically, the speech largely avoided mentioning Reform UK or Nigel Farage, choosing instead to focus on the "failings" of the current government.
• Conference Choreography: Significant effort was made by CCHQ to choreograph Baydon's exit from the hall, ensuring she was flanked by "adoring activists" in a smaller venue. The "pantomime-esque moment" during the stamp duty reveal was noted for creating a sense of excitement and engagement among activists.

Synthesis and Conclusion

Chem Baydon's conference speech successfully aimed to stabilize her leadership and articulate a clearer vision for the Conservative Party, pivoting towards economic issues and fiscal conservatism. The proposed abolition of stamp duty and the "new golden economic rule" are central to this strategy, offering distinct policy proposals while emphasizing responsible public finances. While the speech's confident delivery and strategic framing against Labour were positive, the party faces significant challenges, including winning the next election, funding its proposals, and cutting through the "political noise." The controversy surrounding the collapsed Chinese spying case further highlights the complex political landscape and provides a sharp point of attack against the current government's foreign policy. The conference's overall success for Baydon was largely attributed to her improved personal performance and the clear articulation of a renewed policy direction.