Capital markets and consumer lending will be 'topical businesses': MacDonald on bank earnings

Key Concepts

• Capital Markets: Financial services involving equity, derivatives, fixed income, and currency trading.
• Forward-Looking Earnings: A valuation metric based on projected future earnings rather than historical data.
• Return on Equity (ROE): A measure of financial performance calculated by dividing net income by shareholders' equity.
• Net Interest Margin (NIM): The difference between interest income generated by banks and the amount of interest paid out to depositors.
• Yield Curve: A graph showing the relationship between interest rates and the time to maturity of debt for a given borrower in a given currency.
• Oligopoly: A market structure dominated by a small number of large firms (in this case, the "Big Six" Canadian banks).

---

1. Market Overview and Valuations

Canadian bank stocks have outperformed the broader TSX index, rising 16% year-to-date compared to the TSX’s 9%. Current valuations for the "Big Six" banks are trading at an average of 15 times forward-looking earnings, significantly higher than the 10-year average of 11 times. There is a notable divergence in valuations, ranging from 13x to 17x, driven by the specific business mix of each institution.

2. Key Business Drivers

Alexander McDonald identifies two primary areas of focus for the upcoming earnings reports:

• Capital Markets: This sector has been a major tailwind, contributing to 25% of recent earnings revisions. Since 2019, capital markets revenue has grown at a 10% annual rate. Banks with higher exposure to equity and derivatives (e.g., National Bank) have seen higher valuations. However, this revenue is volatile and dependent on market activity.
• Consumer Lending: The Canadian economy faces headwinds, including rising unemployment (approaching 7%), increased credit card delinquencies, and a housing market down 20% from 2022 highs. While mortgage growth may remain stagnant, banks may see Net Interest Margin (NIM) expansion as the yield curve steepens, allowing them to lend at higher rates than they pay on deposits.

3. Bank-Specific Analysis

• National Bank: Overweight in equity and derivatives trading, which has driven strong performance and a higher valuation (near 17x). The risk is that this revenue is highly sensitive to market volatility.
• Royal Bank (RBC): Viewed as a "beast" with a highly diversified business model. While it has lagged in stock performance compared to peers due to lower exposure to the volatile trading upside, it maintains high ROEs. It is considered a defensive play if market volatility subsides.
• Bank of Nova Scotia (Scotiabank): Currently undergoing a strategic reorientation under new management to focus on the North American market.
  • Goal: Improve Canadian banking ROE from the current 16% toward the 24% target.
  • Strategy: Aggressive client acquisition, specifically targeting the 2021 cohort of borrowers whose ultra-low-rate mortgages will come up for renewal in 2026.
  • Valuation: Trading at ~13x, the lowest in the group, making it an attractive value play.

4. Competitive Landscape: Fintech vs. Big Banks

McDonald argues that while fintech firms like Wealthsimple and Questrade provide healthy competition and force innovation, they are unlikely to cause "material disruption" to the Canadian banking oligopoly. He notes that the Canadian banks are incredibly resilient, having survived the 2009 financial crisis better than their U.S. counterparts, and possess the capital and scale to adapt their offerings to match fintech innovations.

5. Notable Quotes

• "The banks are coming fast and furious this week... That has caused valuations to expand a little bit." — Alexander McDonald on the upcoming earnings cycle.
• "Equity capital markets has actually grown at about 12% and that fixed income side is only grown at about nine." — Highlighting the shift in revenue drivers within capital markets.
• "It's an oligopoly... it's a pillar of the Canadian economy. They will innovate... but I don't think it's going to be a material disruption." — On the threat posed by fintech competitors.

---

Synthesis and Conclusion

The Canadian banking sector is currently characterized by high valuations and a reliance on capital markets for growth. Investors should monitor the divergence between banks heavily exposed to volatile equity markets versus those with more diversified, lending-focused models. While consumer credit risks are rising, the potential for NIM expansion and strategic pivots (like Scotiabank’s) provide specific opportunities. Overall, the "Big Six" remain stable, dominant pillars of the economy, well-positioned to absorb competitive pressure from fintechs through innovation.