Canada's New Evidence-Based ETFs

Key Concepts

• Factor Investing: An investment strategy that targets specific drivers of return (factors) such as size, value, and profitability, rather than just market capitalization.
• Market Capitalization (Cap) Weighting: A method where stocks are held in proportion to their total market value; the standard for most index funds.
• Expected Return Premiums: The theoretical and empirical evidence that certain types of stocks (small, cheap, profitable) have higher expected returns than the broad market.
• Tracking Error: The divergence between the price behavior of a portfolio and its benchmark index.
• Implicit Costs: Hidden costs in index funds, such as those incurred during mandatory rebalancing or index inclusion (e.g., buying IPOs at inflated prices).
• Dividend Discount Model: A financial framework used to value stocks based on the present value of future dividends, which serves as the theoretical basis for factor premiums.

---

1. The Shift from Active Management to Factor-Based ETFs

The Canadian investment landscape is dominated by high-fee, actively managed funds (over 80% of the market). While low-cost index funds are a significant improvement, they are not perfect.

• The Problem with Indexing: Cap-weighted index funds are "mechanical." They must buy stocks when they are added to an index (e.g., IPOs) and sell when they are removed, often at unfavorable prices. Research suggests this systematic trading results in an implicit cost of approximately 0.5% per year.
• The Avantis/CIBC Solution: These new ETFs provide a "middle ground"—they are not traditional active management (which rarely beats the market), but they are also not passive index funds. They use a systematic, evidence-based approach to tilt portfolios toward stocks with higher expected returns.

2. The Theoretical Framework: Fama-French Five-Factor Model

The strategy is rooted in the 2015 Fama-French asset pricing model. Using the Dividend Discount Model, the theory posits that:

• Value Premium: Stocks with a lower price-to-book ratio have higher expected returns.
• Profitability Premium: Stocks with higher expected earnings (relative to price) have higher expected returns.
• Investment Premium: Companies with higher asset growth (aggressive investment) tend to have lower expected returns.

Key Insight: These factors should not be pursued in isolation. For example, "cheap" stocks (value) without profitability can be "cheap for a reason" (distressed). Avantis targets stocks that are simultaneously smaller, cheaper, and more profitable.

3. The Avantis CIBC ETF Lineup

These funds are designed to be low-cost and broadly diversified, with management fees ranging from 0.19% to 0.39%.

| Ticker | Focus | Strategy | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | CACE | Canadian Equity | Total market with tilts toward small, cheap, profitable stocks. | | CLV | US Large Cap Value | Large caps only; excludes high-priced growth stocks. | | CAUS | US All Cap | Total US market with moderate tilts. | | CAUV | US Small Cap Value | Aggressive tilt toward small, cheap, profitable US stocks. | | CADE | International Equity | Developed markets (ex-Canada) with moderate tilts. | | CASV | Global Small Cap Value | Global exposure to small, cheap, profitable firms. | | CA | All-Equity Asset Allocation | A "one-stop-shop" ETF (similar to VEQT) containing the above funds. |

4. Important Considerations and Trade-offs

• Tracking Error: Because these funds intentionally deviate from market-cap weights, they will perform differently than the broad market. This can lead to periods of underperformance that may be psychologically difficult for investors.
• IPO Exposure: Unlike index funds, which are forced to buy IPOs at potentially inflated prices, Avantis funds evaluate the financials of new listings before deciding to include them.
• Accessibility: Previously, Canadians had to use US-listed ETFs (like those from Dimensional Fund Advisors), which involved currency conversion, tax complexities (foreign withholding tax), and administrative burdens. The new CIBC-listed ETFs eliminate these hurdles.

5. Notable Quotes

• "Index funds are the investing equivalent of never interrupt your enemy when they're making a mistake." — Ben Felix, regarding how index funds benefit from the market-efficiency efforts of active managers.
• "The stocks with the highest expected returns in the market will tend to be the stocks with both low relative prices and robust profitability."

Synthesis and Conclusion

The launch of the Avantis CIBC ETFs represents a significant evolution for Canadian retail investors. While low-cost, cap-weighted index funds remain a sensible choice for most, these new ETFs offer a sophisticated, evidence-based alternative for those seeking to capture multiple return premiums (size, value, and profitability). By moving away from the mechanical constraints of index tracking, these funds aim to mitigate implicit costs and improve long-term expected returns, provided the investor has the discipline to withstand the inevitable periods of tracking error and underperformance relative to the broad market.