Anthropic Faces US Deadline Over Pentagon AI Feud | The Pulse 2/27

The Pulse with Francine Lacqua - Summary (October 26, 2023)

Key Concepts:

• Anthropic/DoD Standoff: Dispute over the use of Anthropic’s Claude AI platform by the U.S. Department of Defense, specifically regarding surveillance and autonomous weapons systems.
• Netflix/Warner Bros./Paramount Deal: Failed acquisition of Warner Bros. Discovery by Netflix, ultimately resulting in Paramount Global securing a deal with Skydance Media.
• Private Credit Market Concerns: Emerging risks and potential systemic issues within the non-bank private credit sector, highlighted by recent asset markdowns and company collapses.
• Geopolitical Shifts: Analysis of evolving international relations, including U.S.-Iran nuclear talks, China’s role in global affairs, and European hedging strategies.
• AI Disruption: Discussion of the broader implications of Artificial Intelligence, including ethical concerns, economic impacts, and investment strategies.

---

1. Anthropic & the U.S. Department of Defense Dispute

The core of the program focused on the escalating standoff between Anthropic, an AI company, and the U.S. Department of Defense (DoD). Anthropic refused the DoD’s latest offer, objecting to the potential use of its Claude AI platform for domestic surveillance of U.S. citizens and for lethal strikes without human intervention. Anthropic stated they “don’t know exactly how our platform would go during these situations and don’t think it’s safe and can’t in good conscience agree to that.”

The DoD responded by asserting its right to dictate how purchased platforms are utilized, framing the issue as a matter of national security. A 5:00 PM deadline was imposed by Pete Hegseth, threatening to remove Anthropic from all U.S. military systems (a “supply chain list” exclusion) or invoke a 1950s-era law allowing the military to use the platform regardless of Anthropic’s consent.

The potential consequences of failing to reach a deal include significant disruption to military applications already utilizing Claude, including systems within Boeing and Lockheed Martin. The dispute is also framed within a broader political context, with Anthropic’s CEO having supported Kamala Harris in the 2024 election and a historical split between the Trump administration and the company.

2. Netflix, Warner Bros., and Paramount Deal Dynamics

The program covered Netflix’s withdrawal from the bidding war for Warner Bros. Discovery, allowing Paramount Global to proceed with a deal with Skydance Media valued at $111 billion. Netflix cited financial discipline as the reason for pulling out, choosing to focus on investing in new content.

The deal’s regulatory approval process remains uncertain. The initial offer from Paramount was $31 per share, which Warner Bros. considered superior to Netflix’s bid.

3. Risks in the Private Credit Market

A significant portion of the discussion centered on growing concerns within the private credit market. Recent events, including asset markdowns at Apollo and the collapse of Market Financial Solutions in London, are raising red flags. The issue stems from a shift of lending activity from regulated banks to less-regulated private lenders, often backed by banks.

Neil Calham, Bloomberg’s Finance Czar, highlighted the lack of buffers within some of these lenders, increasing bank exposure to potential losses. He noted that some lenders had equity-to-lending ratios as low as 2%, compared to 5-7% for banks. Patrick Armstrong suggested a “wall of money” chasing private credit led to lowered lending standards and increased risk. He characterized the situation as a potential “canary in the coal mine,” warning of a possible systemic issue.

4. Geopolitical Landscape & International Relations

The program touched upon several geopolitical developments:

• U.S.-Iran Nuclear Talks: Talks in Geneva yielded no immediate breakthrough, but both sides agreed to reconvene in Vienna. The situation is complicated by President Trump’s continued military pressure and the potential for oil price spikes.
• China’s Growing Influence: Discussions focused on European nations, including Germany and France, seeking to diversify their relationships and hedge against U.S. unpredictability by strengthening ties with China. France’s recent defense deal with India ($33 billion for fighter aircraft) and the EU-India free trade agreement were highlighted.
• UK Political Instability: The Labour Party’s loss of a traditionally safe seat in a by-election to the Green Party was discussed, raising questions about Keir Starmer’s leadership and a potential shift to the left within the Labour Party. The market reaction was noted as favoring stability and centrist policies.

5. The Impact of Artificial Intelligence

The program explored the broader implications of AI, including:

• Ethical Concerns: The Anthropic/DoD dispute underscored the ethical dilemmas surrounding the use of AI in military applications.
• Economic Disruption: The potential for job displacement due to AI-driven automation was acknowledged, with a focus on companies like Block and Twitter reducing staff.
• Investment Strategies: Patrick Armstrong advocated for investing in companies benefiting from the AI infrastructure build-out (hyperscalers like TSMC, Micron, and energy suppliers) rather than directly investing in AI companies themselves. He also favored shorting companies with long durations and aspirational AI plans.
• AI Integration in Business: Veolia’s CEO emphasized the use of AI to improve efficiency across its operations, from water treatment to waste management and rare earth recycling.

6. Veolia’s Business Outlook & Sustainability

Veolia’s CEO discussed the strong demand for the company’s services, driven by increasing concerns about resource security and sustainability. He highlighted the growing importance of rare earth recycling and Veolia’s patented technology for recovering these critical materials from waste streams. He emphasized the company’s resilience to geopolitical events and its focus on local operations.

Notable Quotes:

• Anthropic (via Laura Davison): “We don’t know exactly how our platform would go during these situations and don’t think it’s safe and can’t in good conscience agree to that.”
• Patrick Armstrong: “Markets reward, middle ground, centrist policy, they like gridlock but extremes are dangerous for markets.”
• Patrick Armstrong: “I’m short duration. What the Fed will do and politics will do is unequivocally inflation, steeper yield curve, private credit spread and anything without earnings today I don’t like.”
• Veolia CEO: “Securing critical need, talking about securing supply chain for industries, securing resilience for communities and entering in a way sovereignty by tapping into local resources.”

Data & Statistics:

• Paramount Deal Value: $111 billion
• Veolia’s Revenue from Outside Europe: 40%
• Veolia’s Fighter Aircraft Deal with India: $33 billion Euros
• Crude Oil Price: Around $70 a barrel (potential spike to $100)
• Market Financial Solutions Equity-to-Lending Ratio: 2% (compared to 5-7% for banks)

Conclusion:

The program painted a picture of a complex and rapidly evolving global landscape. The standoff between Anthropic and the DoD highlighted the ethical and strategic challenges posed by AI. Concerns about the private credit market and geopolitical instability added to the sense of uncertainty. Investment strategies focused on benefiting from the infrastructure supporting AI and prioritizing resilience in a volatile environment. The overarching theme was the need for careful navigation in a world characterized by increasing disruption and interconnectedness.