After early gains, questions emerge over Trump’s hold on Republican support | DW News

Key Concepts

• State Capture: The process by which political, legal, and economic institutions are manipulated by a ruling power to serve private or partisan interests rather than the public good.
• Primarying: A political strategy where a party leader threatens to support a challenger against an incumbent member of their own party during the primary election, effectively forcing the incumbent to align with the leader's agenda.
• Majority-Minority Districts: Electoral districts designed to ensure that minority populations have a fair opportunity to elect representatives of their choice; recently challenged by U.S. Supreme Court rulings.
• Populism: A political approach that claims to represent the "common people" against a perceived corrupt elite, often characterized by shifting narratives and the consolidation of power.
• Big Tent Strategy: A political methodology involving the unification of diverse groups (across the political spectrum) to form a majority against an incumbent, as demonstrated in the Hungarian election.

---

1. The State of the Trump Administration

• Approval Ratings: President Trump’s approval has dropped to 35%, with 70% of respondents disapproving of his management of the cost of living.
• Economic Factors: The primary driver of his declining popularity is inflation, specifically rising costs for gasoline and food. This contradicts his campaign promise to lower prices.
• The "Slush Fund" Controversy: The administration attempted to establish a $1.8 billion compensation fund for individuals prosecuted for the January 6th Capitol riot. The fund was abandoned due to Republican backlash, though Professor Kim Lane Scheppele notes that the administration is likely seeking alternative legal avenues to revive it.
• Immunity Provisions: A critical, ongoing component of the proposed settlement includes provisions to immunize Trump, his family, and his businesses from tax authority investigations indefinitely.

2. Congressional Dynamics and Party Control

• The "Primary" Threat: Trump maintains control over the Republican Party by threatening to "primary" any lawmaker who dissents. Because these members are beholden to a firm, pro-Trump minority electorate during the primary stage, they are effectively "cowed" into compliance.
• Institutional Capture: Professor Scheppele argues that the U.S. system is being "rigged" through the judiciary. She highlights that two of the three Supreme Court justices appointed during Trump’s first term were confirmed under "questionable circumstances"—one by blocking an Obama nominee and another by rushing a confirmation following the death of Justice Ginsburg.

3. The MAGA Movement

• Minority Power: While the MAGA movement represents only about one-third of the population, it is a highly organized and firm voting bloc. This is sufficient to dominate primary elections and influence the political narrative, especially when the opposition (the Democratic Party) is in disarray.
• Narrative Flexibility: The movement is characterized by its ability to shift narratives rapidly based on Trump’s directives, as seen with figures like Marjorie Taylor Greene and Tucker Carlson.

4. Lessons from Hungary: The Case of Viktor Orbán

• The Hungarian Model: Viktor Orbán is identified as a model for Trump. Orbán successfully rigged the electoral system by ensuring rural votes carried significantly more weight than urban votes.
• The "Big Tent" Success: Challenger Péter Magyar defeated Orbán by:
  • Grassroots Engagement: Spending two years visiting villages to expose state corruption.
  • Unified Opposition: Building a "big tent" coalition that united everyone outside of Orbán’s hardcore base.
  • Systemic Mastery: Understanding the rigged electoral rules (including bonus seats for majorities) and using them to flip districts that had supported Orbán for decades.

5. Synthesis and Conclusion

Professor Scheppele concludes that while Trump’s policies are unpopular, his grip on the Republican Party remains firm due to the threat of primary challenges and the ongoing capture of key institutions like the judiciary. However, the Hungarian experience offers a strategic blueprint for the U.S. opposition:

• Actionable Insight: To defeat a populist leader who has captured the system, the opposition must move beyond traditional left-right divides.
• The Narrative: The most effective strategy is to focus on corruption—specifically how the administration’s self-serving actions (the "slush fund," tax immunity, and institutional rigging) are directly responsible for the degradation of public services like healthcare and education. By framing the issue as a struggle against corruption rather than a partisan battle, the opposition can build the broad coalition necessary to overcome a minority-led populist movement.

"Any very big firm block is going to win even if it's a minority block... [The opposition needs] a strong story that's neither left nor right." — Professor Kim Lane Scheppele