“A shame on the conscience of humanity” Spanish FM on Gaza and Lebanon | UpFront

Key Concepts

• Strategic Autonomy: The concept of Europe developing its own military capabilities to reduce reliance on the United States.
• Transatlantic Relationship: The diplomatic and security partnership between the US and Europe, currently under strain due to trade and security policy disagreements.
• International Law & Multilateralism: The foundational principles guiding Spanish foreign policy, specifically adherence to the UN Charter and International Court of Justice (ICJ) rulings.
• European Defense Integration: The initiative to unify European defense industries and military capacities.
• Bilateral Treaty Framework: The legal agreement governing the use of Spanish military bases by the US, requiring compliance with international law.

---

1. European Strategic Autonomy and NATO

Foreign Minister Jose Manuel Alvarez argues that Europe must develop its own standing army to ensure regional security. He clarifies that this is not intended to undermine NATO, but rather to complement it.

• Rationale: The US administration has signaled a shift in its commitment to the transatlantic relationship, specifically regarding trade tariffs and security burdens.
• Geopolitical Context: The ongoing war in Ukraine and the expansion of conflict in the Middle East necessitate that Europe takes greater responsibility for its own deterrence.
• NATO Contribution: Spain remains a "fundamental and indispensable" ally, citing its deployment of 4,000 soldiers on the eastern flank, air security missions in the Baltics, and the operation of a Patriot battery in Turkey.

2. US-Spain Bilateral Relations

The interview addresses tensions regarding the use of Spanish military bases and potential US retaliation.

• Base Usage: Spain denied the US access to joint military bases for operations against Iran, citing the bilateral treaty which mandates that base usage must comply with international law and the UN Charter.
• Economic Stance: Despite threats from the US regarding trade and troop withdrawals, Alvarez maintains that Spain is not seeking a dispute. He highlights Spain’s economic resilience, noting a record 22 million employees and a growth rate currently outpacing France and Germany.
• Diversification: Spain is actively seeking to diversify its partnerships (e.g., Mercosur, India, Australia) to ensure economic and security stability, not as a replacement for the US, but as a "wider choice of partners."

3. Stance on the Middle East and International Justice

Spain has adopted a distinct position regarding the conflict in Gaza and Lebanon, characterized by strong criticism of Israeli military actions.

• Policy Actions: Spain has withdrawn its ambassador from Israel and introduced a bill to embargo the sale of weapons and military technology to Israel.
• Core Argument: Alvarez emphasizes "coherence" in foreign policy—applying the same standards to the Middle East as are applied to Ukraine. He argues that international law, the protection of civilians, and the sovereignty of nations (including Lebanon) are non-negotiable European values.
• Accountability: Regarding the International Criminal Court (ICC) arrest warrants, Alvarez stated, "Spain will always fully comply with international law and with international justice," implying that if Benjamin Netanyahu were to enter Spanish airspace, the government would act in accordance with its legal obligations.

4. The Future of the European Union

Reflecting on 40 years of EU membership, Alvarez views the union as a "success story" that has fostered prosperity and democracy.

• Integration: He advocates for continued movement toward deeper integration, including the single market and currency.
• Credibility: Alvarez argues that the EU’s global credibility depends on its refusal to apply "double standards." He asserts that the world expects Europe to defend human rights and international law regardless of the power of the actors involved.

---

Synthesis and Conclusion

The interview highlights a pivotal shift in Spanish foreign policy: a move toward greater European strategic autonomy while maintaining a commitment to the transatlantic alliance. Minister Alvarez frames Spain’s actions—both in its refusal to support US military operations in the Middle East and its vocal criticism of Israel—as a principled defense of international law and the UN Charter. By balancing economic growth with a firm stance on human rights, Spain positions itself as a leader in the push for a more integrated, values-driven European foreign policy that is less dependent on the shifting political winds of Washington.