8 Stocks You Want To Buy: TAP, HELE, NWL, MDLZ, GIS, LW, PEP, QFIN
By Value Investing with Sven Carlin, Ph.D.
Stocks You Wish to Buy: A Detailed Analysis of Potential Investments
Key Concepts: Value Investing, Dividend Yield, Free Cash Flow, Capital Allocation, Brand Value, Intangible Assets, Impairment, Leverage, Competitive Advantage, Margin of Safety, Economic Moats, Chinese Market Risks, Regulatory Intervention.
I. Core Beverages (Pablo Molson) – A Declining Business with Questionable Valuation
The analysis begins with Pablo Molson Core Beverages, presented as a seemingly attractive value play due to its dividend and share buybacks. However, a deeper dive reveals significant concerns.
- Declining Revenues: The core issue is declining volumes due to intense competition in the beverage market. Consumers have a limited daily intake capacity, impacting revenue growth.
- Free Cash Flow Concerns: While the free cash flow yield appears high (14-15%), the speaker cautions against a superficial assessment. Revenue stagnation over the past decade and fluctuating earnings raise red flags.
- Acquisition History & Impairments: The company spent $12-14.5 billion on acquisitions, but its current market capitalization is only $9 billion, indicating poor capital allocation. Goodwill impairments have already occurred ($3 billion), but a substantial $12 billion in other intangible assets remain potentially subject to future write-downs.
- Tangible Book Value: The speaker asserts the real tangible book value is “absolute zero,” as the company’s value is heavily reliant on brand equity, which is eroding with declining sales.
- Dividend Yield Assessment: A 3.6% dividend yield is deemed insufficient given the uncertain growth prospects, high competition, and history of poor capital allocation. The speaker suggests a minimum yield of 6-7% to compensate for the risk, aligning with a 2-3 percentage point premium over the 10-year treasury.
- Potential Takeover: While a private equity takeover is possible, the abundance of cheap food brands and the competitive landscape make it less likely.
Quote: “The real tangible book value here is absolute zero. It's all based on the value of the brand and the brand is as valuable as long as you can sell more of it. Sales are declining.”
II. Helen of Troy & Newell Brands – Examples of Brand Destruction
Helen of Troy and Newell Brands are presented as cautionary tales of brands lacking a sustainable competitive advantage.
- Lack of Competitive Advantage: Despite claims of strong brands, both companies are experiencing declining sales and margins.
- Financial Distress: Newell Brands’ interest expense ($60 million) equals 15% of its market capitalization, effectively meaning bondholders control the company. The company is at risk of bankruptcy if leverage ratios worsen.
- Balance Sheet Illusions: A price-to-book ratio of 0.5 appears to offer a margin of safety, but the speaker emphasizes that the assets are largely comprised of inventory and intangible assets (goodwill and other intangibles) that are likely overvalued and subject to impairment.
- Negative Equity: Newell Brands has negative stockholder equity (-$2.5 billion), with dividends being funded by issuing debt, a practice described as “kicking the can down the road.”
Quote: “You might look at the balance sheet a little bit and you see say but when there is so much assets everything is great…but they don't tell you what the assets are here.”
III. Mondelēz International, General Mills & PepsiCo – Established Food Stocks with Limited Upside
The analysis moves to established food stocks, finding limited compelling investment opportunities.
- Mondelēz: A 3.5% dividend yield is considered insufficient, with growth primarily driven by inflation rather than organic expansion.
- General Mills: A 5% dividend yield is also deemed inadequate given the declining business trends. Potential for a takeover is mentioned, but the yield doesn’t provide sufficient downside protection.
- PepsiCo: A 4% dividend yield and a P/E ratio of 27 are considered uninspiring, offering only a 4% total return. The speaker concludes there are “no miracles” and the stock doesn’t align with investment goals.
IV. Qin (China) – A High-Risk, High-Reward Opportunity
The discussion shifts to Qin, a Chinese lending platform, presenting a potentially lucrative but highly risky investment.
- Attractive Metrics: Qin boasts an 8% dividend yield and a P/E ratio of 2, coupled with significant share buybacks. It facilitates lending through an app with 62 million approved credit lines and 30 million users.
- Significant Risks: The stock has stagnated for five years, and delinquency rates are rising (5%). The speaker highlights the inherent risks of investing in Chinese companies, including regulatory intervention and potential capital controls.
- Past Experience: The speaker recounts a previous successful (but largely luck-based) investment in a Chinese company, emphasizing the need for deep understanding of the regulatory environment.
- Due Diligence Challenges: Assessing capital protections and the ability to repatriate dividends from China is deemed difficult.
Quote: “That’s called interventionism into free market. That’s communism. Huh? See, interesting.” (referring to potential regulatory changes in China)
V. Methodology & Framework for Investment Evaluation
Throughout the analysis, the speaker consistently applies a value investing framework, focusing on:
- Free Cash Flow Analysis: Assessing the sustainability and quality of cash flows.
- Capital Allocation: Evaluating management’s decisions regarding acquisitions, dividends, and share buybacks.
- Brand Strength & Competitive Advantage: Determining whether a company possesses a durable economic moat.
- Dividend Yield & Total Return: Seeking a yield that provides adequate compensation for risk, ideally with a premium over the 10-year treasury.
- Balance Sheet Scrutiny: Looking beyond headline metrics (like P/B ratio) to understand the true value of assets and liabilities.
Conclusion
The speaker concludes that finding compelling investment opportunities in the current market is challenging. The analysis highlights the importance of rigorous due diligence, a focus on sustainable competitive advantages, and a cautious approach to companies with declining revenues, questionable capital allocation, or exposure to significant regulatory risks. The speaker emphasizes the need to prioritize investments that offer a sufficient margin of safety and align with long-term investment goals. He encourages viewers to utilize his research platform for further insights into his own portfolio holdings.
Chat with this Video
AI-PoweredHi! I can answer questions about this video "8 Stocks You Want To Buy: TAP, HELE, NWL, MDLZ, GIS, LW, PEP, QFIN". What would you like to know?