3 Misunderstood Stocks to Buy I May 18, 2026
By Morningstar, Inc.
Key Concepts
- Signal vs. Noise: The core framework for distinguishing between information that fundamentally alters a company’s long-term intrinsic value (signal) and temporary market fluctuations or "blips" (noise).
- Intrinsic Valuation: The present value of all future free cash flows a company will generate over its lifetime.
- Economic Moat: A company’s durable competitive advantage (e.g., network effect, cost advantage, intangible assets) that protects its market share and profitability over 10–20+ years.
- Margin of Safety: The difference between a stock's current market price and its intrinsic value, providing a buffer against risk.
- Hyperscaler: Large-scale cloud computing providers (e.g., AWS, Azure, Google Cloud) that drive significant demand for hardware and AI infrastructure.
1. Defining Signal vs. Noise
Dave Sekera defines signal as information that necessitates a meaningful revision (typically 10% or more) to long-term intrinsic valuation models. Noise, conversely, consists of temporary events—such as weather-related disruptions, one-off legal costs, or foreign exchange (FX) translation swings—that do not alter the long-term business trajectory.
- Key Indicators of Signal:
- Unexpected management changes (often indicating board-level concern over business dynamics).
- Accounting irregularities (a major red flag).
- New competitive threats that erode a company’s economic moat.
- Sustained shifts in revenue growth or margin expansion/contraction.
- Common Noise:
- Quarterly earnings "beats" or "misses" by a few pennies (often managed by companies guiding analysts down).
- Short-term market volatility or sector-wide sell-offs.
2. The Role of Economic Moats
Moats are long-term defenses. Sekera emphasizes that investors must evaluate whether news impacts the "five moat sources."
- AI and Moats: Morningstar recently downgraded several software companies from "wide" to "narrow" moat status due to AI-driven uncertainty.
- Resilience: The network effect is identified as the most robust defense against AI disruption.
- Vulnerability: Switching costs and intangible assets (like patents) are currently viewed as the most at-risk moat sources due to the rapid evolution of AI technology.
3. Methodologies for Filtering Information
Sekera suggests a disciplined approach to processing information:
- Primary Source Analysis: Prioritize 10-Ks, 10-Qs, and investor day presentations over media headlines.
- Conference Call Scrutiny: Listen to the Q&A portion of earnings calls. Pay attention to management’s tone, what they emphasize, and—crucially—what they avoid discussing.
- Competitor Monitoring: Track competitors' product launches and technological advancements to see if they are gaining ground on your holdings.
- The "Semiannual" Risk: Sekera argues that moving from quarterly to semiannual reporting (as proposed by the SEC) would likely increase market volatility and the cost of equity, as information would be less timely and disclosures less frequent.
4. Stock Picks and Case Studies
| Stock | Rating | Thesis | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | Salesforce | 4-Star | Misunderstood due to AI fears; trades at ~12.5x forward earnings. Thesis: AI will enhance product value, shifting the model from "per-seat" to "consumption-based" pricing. | | Ecolab | 4-Star | Noise: Commodity chemical inflation. Reality: The company has successfully navigated similar cost pressures in 2022 and can leverage premium product upselling. | | Edison Int'l | 4-Star | Noise: Wildfire litigation risk. Reality: Trading at 11x earnings (vs. 18x sector average), providing a significant margin of safety despite regulatory headlines. | | Qualcomm | 2-Star | Sell: The stock surged 50% on a vague deal with a "hyperscaler." Sekera warns that without concrete details on revenue impact, the market has priced in too much optimism. |
5. Synthesis and Conclusion
The ability to distinguish signal from noise is a critical skill for long-term success. Investors should avoid "gaming" quarterly results and instead focus on whether new information fundamentally changes a company's long-term cash flow potential or its competitive moat. In the current environment, AI represents a significant source of both noise (market-wide sell-offs) and signal (potential shifts in business models). Investors are encouraged to maintain a long-term perspective, prioritize primary company disclosures, and demand a sufficient margin of safety when uncertainty is high.
Chat with this Video
AI-PoweredLoad the transcript when you're ready to chat so the initial page stays lighter.